Electron Mix Binds Water Molecules
By P. Weiss
Life owes its existence to a relatively weak connection called the hydrogen
bond, which joins molecules or regions within a molecule. Without it, liquid
water would be scarce on Earth and biological machinery involving DNA and
proteins would halt. Despite intense scrutiny, the bond has remained mysterious
in many ways (SN: 7/20/96, p. 37).
A new study of ice now shows experimentally that the frail hydrogen bond
between water molecules taps into a molecule's internal covalent bonds, formed
when atoms share electrons. The late Nobel laureate Linus Pauling first
suggested this might be the case in 1935.
Although scientists have long assumed that hydrogen bonds are partly
covalent, the experimental proof ranks as a major milestone, some hydrogen-bond
experts say. Demonstrated in water, the findings apply to all hydrogen bonds,
they add. The results may help investigators better understand properties of
the bonds, such as why they are strongest in a certain direction, and improve
models of their behavior.
A report on the experiment in the Jan. 18 Physical Review Letters is
"certainly a very, very important new paper," comments Jose Teixeira
of the Saclay research center of France's Atomic Energy Commission.
In water, hydrogen bonds forge links between hydrogen and oxygen atoms in
adjacent molecules. Such a bond's character derives mostly from attraction
between unlike electric charges that the two types of atoms acquire.
However, the new findings show that an electron contributing to that charge
separation spends roughly 10 percent of its time mingling with an electron
covalently binding the hydrogen and oxygen atoms within the adjacent molecule.
"That's what Pauling said, and it's consistent with our data," says
Eric D. Isaacs, the leader of the new study and one of three scientists at
Lucent Technologies' Bell Labs in Murray Hill, N.J., who took part in the work.
The specific 10 percent estimate has not yet been published, he says.
In the new experiment, Isaacs' team, which also included scientists at
Northeastern University in Boston, the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility
in Grenoble, France, and the Canadian National Research Council in Ottawa,
Ontario, shone X rays at millimeter-thick crystals of ultrapure ice. X rays
lose some energy and change direction as they strike electrons in the crystal.
Their transformations reveal the spatial distribution of the ice's
electronsconsidered waves, according to quantum mechanics. By studying X
rays bounced off various planes in the crystal with different numbers of
hydrogen bonds, the team highlighted features of the bonds.
In the portrait of the electron waves that emerged, the team found
fluctuations like those observed when overlapping light waves interfere with
each othertheir crests and troughs adding and canceling. The researchers
deduce that the electron wave in each hydrogen bond is interfering with the
wave in an adjacent covalent bond. Consequently, the electrons in both bonds
must overlap to some degree, indicating that the electron in the hydrogen bond
is circulating around two linked atomsthe hallmark of covalency.