Book Review: Sun in a Bottle: The Strange History of Fusion and the Science of Wishful Thinking
Review by Davide Castelvecchi
Web edition : Friday, October 24th, 2008
font_down font_up Text Size
access
Sun in a Bottle: The Strange History of Fusion and the Science of Wishful Thinking by Charles Seife

Fusion is the source of energy that’s 30 years away, and always will be, skeptics quip.

In principle, the energy released when light atomic nuclei are fused to form heavier ones is much greater than the energy required to coax the light nuclei into fusing in the first place.

That’s how the sun has been shining for billions of years. And ever since the first hydrogen bomb tests in the 1950s, scientists have hoped to reproduce the sun’s magic in a controlled fashion, unlocking an unlimited source of energy. But the dream has been elusive.

With great explanatory skill, Seife, a journalism professor at New York University, explains how fusion works and why it is so hard to get power out of it. Seife reviews the parade of hubristic and sometimes comic or outright dishonest claims that fusion scientists have made over the decades.

Edward Teller proposed using hydrogen bombs to widen the Suez Canal, and Martin Fleischmann and Stanley Pons reported producing a tabletop nuclear fusion reaction at normal temperatures and pressures—“cold fusion.”

But there are also lesser-known episodes. In 1951, for example, Argentine President Juan Perón pompously announced that his country had learned to control fusion with a secret material, which scientists suggested was probably baloney.

Although Seife sometimes goes in circles and makes the same point multiple times, the book — his fourth — is enjoyable, and a must-read for anyone who wants to know the story behind ongoing multibillion-dollar attempts at bottling up the sun.

Viking, 2008, 294 p., $25.95


Comments 3
  • The global collapse of world economies and or global war with Russia over energy is occuring right before our eyes-when will you wake to what is the foundation of any civilized industrialized country- ENERGY- I HAVE SOLVED IT- pressure Princeton university to replicate my experiment to verify- over 17 months i still wait- Lets see how long it takes to uncover

    My experiments will end the energy crisis via nuclear fusion- the only way i can prove it is to have a credible university repeat my experiment- because i hand built a tunable Tesla coil at 1 million volts to resonate within heavy water/deuteron for stable conduction of plasma arc-the experiment is very dangerous and i am grateful to god i survived;) however, what seems even harder than the experiment- is trying to convince my fellow American citizens- i am for real- remember this- soldiers fight and die for energy-our economy is about to be crippled-how long must i be ignored as i try my best to stimulate you to help force a university to just replicate my experiment for verification. if you want to save the world from global war and economic collapse from energy - email Princeton plasma labs and force them to repeat my experiment as they are too arrogant to listen to the deed of a messenger- when my system proves true to save the world of greenhouse gases and clean energy for all nations- you will say- THANK GOD--http://www.pppl.gov/-princeton labs/a> sincerely solomon azar



    They say the rejection of the 700 billion bailout plan the first time was because the republicans were disturbed by the democratic leadership pelosi remarks and thus killed the bill in party protests-even at the expense of the American nation. I would say in 17 months, this is exactly what is happening with me- all who watch are arrogant enough, to shut me down, ignore me, don't like my beliefs,ridicule the possibility/etc etc whatever- all the while our economy and earth drift into decay over the energy crisis- no wonder it took all these years for the children of god bound in the cousin of the monkey body to cultivate this planet so long from beginning.



    The following video was made april 2007 to encourage the largest nuclear power company to investigate my deeds- they do nothing as their faith is weak


    700 billion bailout equals 700 billion per year for foreign oil says t boone pickens- ENERGY is the key to civilization- dont believe me- go live just one day in the woods- the valuable resource is getting dry as india and china want to live a little like the west-cant blame them- who i do blame is being on this net for so long as everyone uses their own arrogance and negativity to ignore solutions for energy- how many people have you met in your life that says they solved it- go ahead and ignore this as the rest in past year- when the total economy fails- dont be puzzled as you did nothing- pressure a university to investigate and repeat- i dont want your money-take your energy and help solve the energy crisis

    Photobucket

    I love the man called jesus-a life of struggle and sacrifice for the betterment of mankind- this is the highest principle of life to live-struggle in any form- you want a strong body- train hard all the time- take one week off and you deteriorate- want a strong mind-read and learn everything as often as you can-want an enlightened soul- love god with all your heart and soul and struggle and sacrifice for the betterment of mankind-Life is a struggle- I wouldn't have it any other way- Free will


    * my name is Solomon Sami Azar-born on the 13th January-1965. I have combined the century old ideas of Tesla and Einstein to produce safe nuclear fusion of heavy water in order to end the energy crisis- When the scientific community has found this and understands -the energy crisis will be over along with talks of greenhouse gases-I have been guided to this discovery by the heavens- by a force in this universe we are all connected to in spirit and pray to in the name of god- I have put together many signs and connections to form the big picture- I am a messenger of GOD---I have been sent by heaven to declare An Age of Unity has begun- world war 2 was Armageddon signified by two atomic bombs-An age of unity has begun
    Lightning Fusion Lightning Fusion
    Oct. 24, 2008 at 1:20pm
  • I believe our path should be that of light. We are now able to tie light frequencies into a weave pattern.

    Lets say we weave this light into a tube. let say the tube connects to itself so we have a loop.

    In my thoughts an electron flying around this ring of light, will release energy into the lattice that is formed by the light.
    The next stage would be a phase/flux - flux/phase - to a ground state, a flux capacitor if you would..heheh

    -Marc Ricciardi
    Marc Ricciardi Marc Ricciardi
    Oct. 26, 2008 at 11:58am
  • This book is mostly about the early history of fusion research, and about the more recent fiascos where maverick researchers have claimed breakthroughs without adequate scientific basis. It devotes relatively little ink to the scientists and engineers worldwide who are working to develop fusion, on the basis of peer-reviewed, replicable research. When I started in this field as a graduate student we made 1/10 of a Watt of fusion heat in a pulse of 1/100 of second. Now the record is in the range of 10 million Watts for a second. That is an improvement by an overall factor of 10 billion. The international ITER project will produce 500 million Watts of fusion heat for periods of at least 300 - 500 seconds. We have further to go, and lots of challenges, but fusion has large advantages in safety, waste and nuclear proliferation. There are relatively few attractive choices for large-scale, long-term, steady electric power production, and they all need to be explored.
    Rob  Goldston Rob Goldston
    Nov. 9, 2008 at 3:50pm
Post a comment

Please login or register to participate.


Advertisement