- :: Atom & Cosmos
- :: Body & Brain
- :: Earth
- :: Environment
- :: Genes & Cells
- :: Humans
- :: Life
- :: Matter & Energy
- :: Molecules
- :: Science & Society
- :: Other Topics
- :: Science News For Kids
New evidence from satellites and weather stations suggests that way down south, Antarctica is feeling the heat. And that’s not good news for penguins.
Scientists studying climate change knew some coastal areas of Antarctica were warming. But data from weather stations inland — at the South Pole and Lake Vostok — indicated these sites were actually getting colder. Researchers suspected that the whipping winds and freezing temperatures that grip these interior regions were keeping the rest of the continent cool, as well.
To check that out, a group of scientists decided to take a cold, hard look at the data. The team combined meteorological records from 42 weather stations in Antarctica together with data collected from satellites. Some of the data went back 50 years. The scientists then devised a new estimate of temperature trends in Antarctica.
It shows that much of this continent — particularly the West Antarctic Ice Sheet — had been warming in recent decades. This region makes up about one-quarter of the continent and has a lower average elevation than does East Antarctica. The new analysis showed that, overall, West Antarctica is warming about 0.17 degrees Celsius per decade, a rate comparable to the average elsewhere in the world. A description of their findings appeared in the Jan. 21 issue of Science News.
Just as the scientists suspected, parts of East Antarctica had cooled slightly between 1957 and 2006. But overall, warming in that portion of the continent — a far larger area — more than offset the cooling noted at the South Pole and Lake Vostok.
Antarctica’s warming began somewhat recently, the scientists suspect. The rise in temperature was most likely spurred by various dramatic changes. For example, vast areas of sea ice off the Antarctic coast have shrunken over the past 25 years. The loss of that sea ice has, in turn, helped open West Antarctica to storms carrying warm, moist air and snow.
“The new results … indicate that there’s warming related to greenhouse gases on all seven of Earth’s continents,” says Drew Shindell. He’s a climatologist at the NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies in New York City and coauthor of the new study.
Melting ice sheets could also spell disaster for the continent’s wildlife. In another new study, this one reported in the January 26 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, researchers focused on emperor penguins that rely upon the winter sea ice to breed.
Data gathered at a penguin rookery in Terre Adélie, Antarctica, showed that when winter sea ice dropped an average of 11 percent for several consecutive years, the penguin population also took a nosedive. During that period, the population fell to half its normal number. When the sea ice reached high levels, penguin populations remained high.
If Antarctic ice sheets continue melting at a high rate, emperor penguins could nearly be wiped out, says Hal Caswell, a mathematical ecologist at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, in Massachusetts.
Even if sea-ice melting slows, the overall number of penguins is still likely to continue falling. A study developed by Caswell and his colleagues looked at current penguin-population trends together with estimates of how much sea ice will be available in coming years. These analyses indicate that the Terre Adélie rookery could host only 400 breeding pairs by the end of this century. Forty years ago, there were 15 times that many.
POWER WORDS
Antarctica: The rock and ice-covered continent, the southernmost one on Earth.
Lake Vostok: The largest of more than 140 lakes present under the surface of Antarctica.
South Pole: The southern end of Earth’s axis of rotation, which is a point in Antarctica.
satellite: A body that orbits a planet. Natural ones are called moons. Artificial ones are launched into space and used for research, communications, gleaning weather information, and navigation.
rookery: Where certain birds or animals, such as penguins and seals, gather to breed.
Going Deeper
Polar Ice Feels the Heat
http://www.sciencenewsforkids.org/articles/20080423/Feature1.asp
and Earth's Poles in Peril
http://www.sciencenewsforkids.org/articles/20070530/Feature1.asp
Found in: Climate Change, Earth Science, Ecology, Environment, Life and Science News For Kids
- Antarctica is getting warmer too
- FOR KIDS: In Antarctica watch the heat (and your step)
- Cold and Deep: Antarctica's Lake Vostok has two big neighbors
- Emperor penguins left in the cold with shrinking sea ice
- Of penguins' range and climate change
- Don't like it hot
- Cool Birds
- Deep hole spotted on moon
- Visual illusion stumps adults but not kids
- Mummies reveal heart disease plagued ancient Egyptians
- Malaria shows signs of resisting best drug used to fight it
- Climate not really what doomed large North American mammals


http://www.sciencenews.org/index/generic/activity/view/id/40111
But this time it's all about those cute, fuzzy penguins.
The alleged temperature trend is just statistical noise, well below the accuracy (+/- 2 to 3 deg. C) of the data. Even if it were real, I think penguins can easily adapt to an increase of 0.5 deg. C over 50 years. After all, they easily adapt to far greater temperature swings every 24 hours.
The article is just another unscientific way to hype global warming by tying it to cute and fuzzy animals.
From sepp.org:
"Is Antarctic Warming Real or is it “Mann”-made?
The report of an unexpected Antarctic warming trend [Eric J. Steig, David P. Schneider, Scott D. Rutherford, Michael E. Mann, Josefino C. Comiso & Drew T. Shindell. Warming of the Antarctic ice-sheet surface since the 1957 International Geophysical Year. Nature 457:459-463, 22 Jan. 2009; doi:10.1038/nature07669] has created a certain amount of skepticism – even among supporters of AGW.
But in an AP news story, two of its authors (one is ‘hockey-stick’ inventor Michael Mann from the Real Climate blog) argue that this refutes the skeptics and is "consistent with" greenhouse warming. Of course, as Roger Pielke, Jr, points out, not long ago we learned from Real Climate that a cooling Antarctica was ‘consistent with’ greenhouse warming and thus the skeptics were wrong: “So a warming Antarctica and a cooling Antarctica are both ‘consistent with’ model projections of global warming. Our foray into the tortured logic of ‘consistent with’ in climate science raises the perennial question, what observations of the climate system would be inconsistent with the model predictions?”
The results are based on very few isolated data from weather stations, plus data from research satellites. And here is the rub: these are not data from microwave sounding units (MSU), such as are regularly published by Christy and Spencer, but data from infrared sensors that are supposed to measure the temperature of the surface (rather than of the overlaying atmosphere, as weather stations do).
But the IR emission depends not only on temperature of the surface, but also on surface emissivity -- and is further modified by absorption of clouds and haze.
These are all difficult points. Emissivity of snow depends on its porosity and size of snow crystals. Blowing snow likely has a different emissivity than snow that has been tamped down; so surface winds could have a strong influence. The emissivity of ice is again different and will depend on whether there is a thin melt layer of water on top of the ice, temporarily produced by solar radiation. Finally, we have temperature inversions that can trap haze which is essentially undetectable by optical methods from satellites.
The proof of the pudding, of course, is the MSU data, which show a continuous cooling trend, are little affected by surface conditions and are unaffected by haze and clouds. They are therefore more reliable."
Please login or register to participate.