Advertisement

Science Friday
Winter birds shift north
New Audubon report suggests climate change is the culprit
Web edition : Tuesday, February 10th, 2009
font_down font_up Text Size
access
GOING NORTHOverall the winter ranges of 305 common North American birds have shifted north, according to data from Christmas Bird Counts analyzed by the National Audubon Society.Credits, clockwise from top left: Glenn Tepke; Tim Bowman, USFWS; Steve Maslowski, USFWS; Ryan Hagerty, USFWS.

North could be the new south for wintering birds.

More than half of 305 widespread bird species across North America are spending their winters farther north than they did 40 years ago, says a report released February 10 by the National Audubon Society.

Those shifts dovetail with warming trends in winter temperatures recorded by state during that time, says Audubon scientist Greg Butcher, coauthor of the report. Overall the wintering grounds of the birds have shifted an average of 56 kilometers (35 miles) north in cold months during the past four decades.

Some have moved much more, including red-breasted mergansers (510 kilometers or 317 miles) and purple finches (504 kilometers or 313 miles).

access
Overall the winter ranges of 305 common North American birds have shifted north. Data from Christmas Bird Counts allowed National Audubon Society researchers to calculate changes in the center of abundance for a species.D. Niven et al./Audubon Society

Details of the movement pattern, such as greater shifts in places having more marked temperature changes, suggest climate change is driving the shifts, Butcher says. “We’re showing that global warming isn’t something that’s going to happen far away, say in the Arctic and Antarctic, and it’s not something that might happen in the future,” he says. “It’s something that’s already happened and has been occurring over the last 40 years.”

Woodland birds in the study moved the most, averaging more than a 113-kilometer (70-mile) northward shift in range, more than twice the average change in any other bird group in the study. Not all the species went north. For example, nine of the grassland species moved south, a change that may be attributed to factors beyond temperature.

Butcher and his colleagues drew on data from the Christmas Bird Counts, a 109-year-old tradition in which birders brave whatever winter throws at them to visit predetermined sites where they record all the species they can find during a 24-hour period. In recent years, more than 50,000 volunteers have turned out for the count at some 2,000 locations across the continent.

Such citizen science efforts offer a way to grasp broad trends, says conservation biologist Stuart Butchart of BirdLife International, headquartered in Cambridge, England.

“The strength of this study is that it’s looking at a broad range of species across a large geographic area,” he says. “It’s the overall pattern that’s important and should be raising alarm bells.”

Species that have large ranges may be a good indicator but may not be the birds most at risk from climate change, Butcher says. Species with small, specialized ranges may not have anywhere safe to go. “We’re terribly worried about Hawaiian forest birds,” he says. Warming temperatures allow mosquitoes to rise higher up mountain slopes, carrying avian malaria that has devastated lowland populations.

And even though birds offer a good source of data, other kinds of creatures with even less mobility may be more affected. “Start with trees,” Butcher says. “Trees are big sedentary organisms.” There could be plenty more impacts that don’t get counted every Christmas.


Found in: Biology, Climate Change and Life
Comments 4
  • Most people agree with the statement that there has been warming in the US since the 1970's. The Christmas bird count is a confirmation of this. Another confirmation is the ice out date for Lake Winnipesaukee here in New Hampshire.

    Since 1970, the rolling average of the previous 5 years’ ice out date has moved ten days earlier; April 27 for the period ending 1970 to April 17 for the period ending 2008. However, the average date of ice out over the last 122 years is April 19. Last year the ice out date was April 23. The earliest date for the 5 year moving average is April 8 for the period ending in 1949.

    Plotting the moving averages shows decades long warming or cooling trends. 1971 and 1972 were the coldest of the century, so by starting a study at the coldest point of the last 100+ years the outcome is predetermined.

    All this proves that our climate is variable and that warming trends in the recent past are similar to the one from 1970 to today. It does nothing to prove that the warming a caused by man or that man can do anything about the warming.
    NHChemist NHChemist
    Feb. 11, 2009 at 3:00pm
  • The article says:

    "Woodland birds in the study moved the most, averaging more than a 113-kilometer (70-mile) northward shift in range, more than twice the average change in any other bird group in the study. Not all the species went north. For example, nine of the grassland species moved south, a change that may be attributed to factors beyond temperature."

    So, the only factor in birds heading north is temperature, but birds that spread south have other factors? It would seem to me that the southward spread would suggest there are factors other than temperature in the northward migration too.

    Given the 109 year record, I'm a bit surprised the report only looks at 40 years of it, a period that included little more than the last warm phase of the Pacific Decadal Oscillation. It would be nice to have more data during the current or past cool phases as that would help distinguish factors other than warming in the changing ranges.
    Ric Werme Ric Werme
    Feb. 13, 2009 at 12:37am
  • What was an mature Ivory Gull doing in New England last month. Oh, I know, since the Polar Bears have all drowned in the ice free Polar Sea, there were no seal carcasses to clean up. So it had to come South.
    ART DAY ART DAY
    Feb. 15, 2009 at 12:23am

  • [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    m9bnat m9bnat2 m9bnat m9bnat2
    Jan. 14, 2010 at 11:31am
Post a comment (Please note: All links will be removed from comments.)

Please login or register to participate.


Advertisement
Suggested Reading:
seperator
  • Other studies showing northward movements in bird ranges in response to climate change: [Go to]
Citations & References:
seperator
  • Niven, Daniel K. et al. 2009. Birds and Climate Change: Ecological Disruption in Motion. Audubon Society, New York, NY. Released Feb. 10.
Reader Favorites:
seperator
SN on the Web:
seperator