Advertisement

Science Friday
Little push turns snail lefties to righties
Bumping an embryo’s cells can switch the direction of its spiral
Web edition : Wednesday, November 25th, 2009
font_down font_up Text Size
access
DIRECTIONSThe same species of snail coils either left or right depending on the positioning of cells when the first four divide into eight. Repositioning those cells with a pair of tiny glass rods (inset) reverses the snail's fate.Kuroda lab (inset: B. Endo)

This is a long way from working in politics. But for a snail, researchers report that just a little nudge of some early-dividing cells can push a youngster from left-leaning to right, or vice versa.

That nudge has to come when the Lymnaea stagnalis’ embryo’s first four cells split into eight, says Reiko Kuroda of the University of Tokyo, who studies chirality, or handedness. In nature, a single gene (not yet identified) acts in the mother snail to control which way offspring coil. Kuroda and her colleagues intervened in the usual development, using tiny glass rods to push four of the newly forming cells in the direction opposite to their usual shift. The repositioning reversed the direction of the snail’s spiral from its otherwise genetically determined left or right twist, the researchers report online November 25 in Nature.

The researchers’ little push reversed the patterns of expression for the embryo’s important nodal gene later in development. After the early rearrangement, embryos that would have been right-spiraling showed nodal activity normal for lefties and vice versa. The altered snails grew up backward but otherwise normal, healthy and fertile.

That a single gene and cell-position shift in the embryonic stage can determine such a big switch in animal form has implications for evolutionary mechanisms, says Stuart Newman of New York Medical College in Valhalla. "Evolution can take big jumps and does not have to proceed by increments."


Found in: Life and Zoology

Comments 3
  • This finding is another point against Darwin's theory of gradualism in the evolution of species.
    Garnel Javier Garnel Javier
    Nov. 27, 2009 at 9:50am
  • Upgrade Evolution Comprehension Beyond Darwin


    A. From "Asymmetry switched in snail (by manipulation)"
    [Link was removed]

    This altered handedness, however, did not pass from generation to generation; offspring of (manipulated) reversed-coiled snails reclaimed the pre-manipulated orientations of their ancestors, suggesting the physical manipulations by researchers did not affect the genetically programmed structural pattern.

    B. Again and again: Upgrade Evolution Comprehension Beyond Darwin

    Physical manipulations that do not result in augmented energy constrainment by the organism do not affect the expression of its primal organism, the gene. (PS: why refer to an organism as "genetically programmed structural pattern"?. Are we genetically programmed structural patterns?)

    Please consider the following concept of the origin and nature of life and organisms, of the origin and nature of cosmic and life evolution:

    - Genes, Earth's primal organisms, and all their take-off organisms - Life in general - are but one of the cosmic forms of mass, of constrained energy formats.

    - The on-going cosmic mass-to-energy reversion since the Big-Bang inflation is resisted by mass, this resistance being the archtype of selection for survival by all forms of mass, including life.

    - The mode of genes', Earth's primal organisms, response to the cultural feed-back signals reaching them from their upper stratum take-off organism is "replicate without change" or "replicate with change". "Replicate with change" is selected in case of proven augmented energy constrainment by the the new generation, this being "better survival". This mode of Life's normal evolution is the mode of energy-mass evolution universally.


    Dov Henis
    (Comments From The 22nd Century)
    Updated Life's Manifest May 2009
    [Link was removed] #2321
    Implications Of E=Total[m(1 + D)]
    [Link was removed] #3108

    [Link was removed]
    Dov Henis Dov Henis
    Nov. 29, 2009 at 11:33am
  • The on-going cosmic mass-to-energy reversion since the Big-Bang inflation is resisted by mass, this resistance being the archtype of selection for survival by all forms of mass, including life.
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    Garry Wertu Garry Wertu
    Jan. 18, 2010 at 1:01pm
Post a comment (Please note: All links will be removed from comments.)

Please login or register to participate.

Advertisement
Citations & References :
seperator
  • Kuroda, Reiko. 2009 Chiral blastomere arrangement dictates zygotic left-right asymmetry pathway in snails. Nature.
    doi:10.1038/nature08597
Reader Favorites:
seperator
SN on the Web:
seperator