Advertisement

Science Friday
Major eruption cooled the climate but went unnoticed
Ice-core records suggest that a major 1809 eruption cooled Earth even before the Tambora eruption and 'the year without a summer'
Web edition : Monday, November 30th, 2009
font_down font_up Text Size

A large, previously unknown volcanic eruption somewhere in the tropics helped make the 1810s the coldest decade of the past 500 years, a new analysis suggests.

Scientists have long known about the 1815 eruption of Indonesia’s Mount Tambora, an eruption whose climate-cooling effect was so large that 1816 is often called “the year without a summer” (SN: 8/30/2008, p. 16). Now, evidence from ice cores taken from polar regions suggests that another major eruption occurred in a remote, unpopulated region of the tropics just a few years before Tambora blew its top, says Jihong Cole-Dai, an environmental chemist at South Dakota State University in Brookings.

Precipitation that fell on Greenland and Antarctica in 1810 and 1811 contained higher-than-normal amounts of sulfates, Cole-Dai and his colleagues report online and in the Nov. 28 Geophysical Research Letters. Some scientists had suggested that those sulfates came from small, local eruptions that happened to occur half a world apart but at the same time, he notes.

But new analyses of those sulfates reveal a shift in ratios of sulfur isotopes that indicate the sulfur had undergone chemical reactions high in the atmosphere. Those results show that the sulfates came from a single, massive eruption large enough to send aerosols into the stratosphere over both the Northern and Southern hemispheres, the researchers contend. That eruption, which probably occurred sometime around February 1809, was about half the size of Tambora and cooled the climate substantially, says Cole-Dai. “Then, before temperatures had a chance to fully recover, Tambora happened,” he adds.


Found in: Earth, Earth Science and Paleontology
Comments 4
  • http://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/10/30/previously-unknown-volcanic-eruption-helped-trigger-cold-decade/ covers the online version of the paper. A solar physicist was quick to note the paper is merely confirmation, but he missed that one paper was written by the author of the new paper. It may be the only thing new in the new paper is evidence of a single large eruption instead of several small eruptions. Hardly "earth shaking" news. Well, it was in 1809....

    Leif Svalgaard (22:38:06) :

    We have seen this kind of hype again and again ["never before seen", "unprecedented", etc]

    This story is old hat:

    Title: Ice core evidence for an explosive tropical volcanic eruption 6
    years preceding Tambora
    Authors: Dai, Jihong; Mosley-Thompson, Ellen; Thompson, Lonnie G.
    Publication: Journal of Geophysical Research (ISSN 0148-0227), vol.
    96, Sept. 20, 1991, p. 17,361-17,366. (JGR Homepage)

    Abstract
    High-resolution analyses of ice cores from Antarctica and Greenland reveal an explosive volcanic eruption in the tropics in A.D. 1809 which is not reflected in the historical record. A comparison in the same ice cores of the sulfate flux from the A.D. 1809 eruption to that from the Tambora eruption (A.D. 1815) indicates a near-equatorial location and a magnitude roughly half that of Tambora. Thus this event should be considered comparable to other eruptions producing large volumes of sulfur-rich gases such as Coseguina, Krakatau, Agung, and El Chichon. The increase in the atmospheric concentration of sulfuric acid may have contributed to the Northern Hemisphere cooling observed in the early nineteenth century and may account partially for the decline in surface temperatures which preceded the eruption of Tambora in A.D. 1815.

    Title: Two major volcanic cooling episodes derived from global marine air temperature, AD 1807-1827
    Authors: Chenoweth, Michael
    Publication: Geophysical Research Letters, Volume 28, Issue 15, p. 2963-2966 (GeoRL Homepage), 2001
    DOI: 10.1029/2000GL012648

    Abstract
    A new data set of global marine air temperature data for the years 1807-1827 is used to show the impact of volcanic eruptions in ~1809 (unlocated) and 1815 (Tambora, Indonesia). Both eruptions produced cooling exceeding that after Krakatoa, Indonesia (1883) and Pinatubo, Philippines (1991). The ~1809 eruption is dated to March-June 1808 based on a sudden cooling in Malaysian temperature data and maximum cooling of marine air temperature in 1809. Two large-scale calibrated proxy temperature records, one from tree-ring-density data, the other using multi-proxy sources are compared to the marine air temperature data. Correlation is highest with maximum latewood density data and lowest with the multi-proxy data.

    but nice to have confirmation....
    Ric Werme Ric Werme
    Nov. 30, 2009 at 10:17pm
  • Nice report, [Link was removed] I like it, very useful with my recent study now.
    Thank you. [Link was removed] [Link was removed]
    Misafir Misafir Misafir Misafir
    Dec. 18, 2009 at 4:43pm

  • [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    m9bnat m9bnat2 m9bnat m9bnat2
    Jan. 9, 2010 at 2:26am
  • hımm [Link was removed] Thank you very nice stories
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed] [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed] [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed] [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed] [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    Manga İndir Manga İndir
    Jan. 15, 2010 at 2:12pm
Post a comment (Please note: All links will be removed from comments.)

Please login or register to participate.


Advertisement
Suggested Reading:
seperator
  • Perkins, S. 2008. Disaster goes global. Science News 174(Aug. 30):16.
    [Go to]
Citations & References:
seperator
  • Cole-Dai, J., et al. 2009. Cold decade (AD 1810-1819) caused by Tambora (1815) and another (1809) stratospheric volcanic eruption. Geophysical Research Letters 36(Nov. 28):L22703-1. Abstract available at
    [Go to]
Reader Favorites:
seperator
SN on the Web:
seperator