Advertisement

Science Friday
Ancient hominids may have been seafarers
Hand axes excavated on Crete suggest hominids made sea crossings to go 'out of Africa'
font_down font_up Text Size

ANAHEIM, Calif. — Human ancestors that left Africa hundreds of thousands of years ago to see the rest of the world were no landlubbers. Stone hand axes unearthed on the Mediterranean island of Crete indicate that an ancient Homo species — perhaps Homo erectus — had used rafts or other seagoing vessels to cross from northern Africa to Europe via at least some of the larger islands in between, says archaeologist Thomas Strasser of Providence College in Rhode Island.

Several hundred double-edged cutting implements discovered at nine sites in southwestern Crete date to at least 130,000 years ago and probably much earlier, Strasser reported January 7 at the annual meeting of the American Institute of Archaeology. Many of these finds closely resemble hand axes fashioned in Africa about 800,000 years ago by H. erectus, he says. H. erectus had spread from Africa to parts of Asia and Europe by at least that time.

Until now, the oldest known human settlements on Crete dated to around 9,000 years ago. Traditional theories hold that early farming groups in southern Europe and the Middle East first navigated vessels to Crete and other Mediterranean islands at that time.

“We’re just going to have to accept that, as soon as hominids left Africa, they were long-distance seafarers and rapidly spread all over the place,” Strasser says. The traditional view has been that hominids (specifically, H. erectus) left Africa via land routes that ran from the Middle East to Europe and Asia. Other researchers have controversially suggested that H. erectus navigated rafts across short stretches of sea in Indonesia around 800,000 years ago and that Neandertals crossed the Strait of Gibraltar perhaps 60,000 years ago.

Questions remain about whether African hominids used Crete as a stepping stone to reach Europe or, in a Stone Age Gilligan’s Island scenario, accidentally ended up on Crete from time to time when close-to-shore rafts were blown out to sea, remarks archaeologist Robert Tykot of the University of South Florida in Tampa. Only in the past decade have researchers established that people reached Crete before 6,000 years ago, Tykot says.

Strasser’s team cannot yet say precisely when or for what reason hominids traveled to Crete. Large sets of hand axes found on the island suggest a fairly substantial population size, downplaying the possibility of a Gilligan Island’s scenario, in Strasser’s view.

In excavations conducted near Crete’s southwestern coast during 2008 and 2009, Strasser’s team unearthed hand axes at caves and rock shelters. Most of these sites were situated in an area called Preveli Gorge, where a river has gouged through many layers of rocky sediment.

At Preveli Gorge, Stone Age artifacts were excavated from four terraces along a rocky outcrop that overlooks the Mediterranean Sea. Tectonic activity has pushed older sediment above younger sediment on Crete, so 130,000-year-old artifacts emerged from the uppermost terrace. Other terraces received age estimates of 110,000 years, 80,000 years and 45,000 years.

These minimum age estimates relied on comparisons of artifact-bearing sediment to sediment from sea cores with known ages. Geologists are now assessing whether absolute dating techniques can be applied to Crete’s Stone Age sites, Strasser says.

Intriguingly, he notes, hand axes found on Crete were made from local quartz but display a style typical of ancient African artifacts.

“Hominids adapted to whatever material was available on the island for tool making,” Strasser proposes. “There could be tools made from different types of stone in other parts of Crete.”

Strasser has conducted excavations on Crete for the past 20 years. He had been searching for relatively small implements that would have been made from chunks of chert no more than 11,000 years ago. But a current team member, archaeologist Curtis Runnels of Boston University, pointed out that Stone Age folk would likely have favored quartz for their larger implements. “Once we started looking for quartz tools, everything changed,” Strasser says.


Found in: Archaeology and Humans

Comments 7
  • This report has significant shortcomings:

    1. It has long been known that hominins were on Crete, see Facchini and Giusberti (1992).

    2. Handaxes, if that is what they are, provide no indication of the presence of Homo erectus.

    3. On the other hand, we have one bone of Homo erectus from Sardinia, another island never connected to a mainland, and also lots of Lower Palaeolithic stone tools.

    4. The description of the terraces sounds suspect: the uppermost terrace is the oldest not because of tectonics, as implied, but because that is always the case when a river cuts progressively deeper.

    5. The writer seems unaware of any of the numerous publications (more than 30) on Pleistocene seafaring, which are all be me. This information has been publicly available for many years at [Link was removed]

    Robert G. Bednarik
    Robert Bednarik Robert Bednarik
    Jan. 10, 2010 at 1:41pm
  • Humans seem very water-adapted. Unlike Ardi et al., water-shedding noses, and downward-pointing body hair. Anti-drowning reflexes, and other very early adaptations to (probably) fish and shellfish hunting. Travel by water would seem natural to such pre-adapted beings.
    Brian Hall Brian Hall
    Jan. 10, 2010 at 7:45pm
  • What was the condition of the Mediterranean 130,000 years ago?
    Daniel Miller Daniel Miller
    Jan. 11, 2010 at 12:44am
  • In Elaine Dewars (not a scientist, but a journalist who contacted many scientists, native rights people, etc.)book 'Bones', she discussed a 'found and then lost' coulette (sp? The Top of an Erectus Skull) that a Brazillian Researcher found in the Amazon.
    We need to do more Archaeology in the strata that date to these time-periods; as not looking in those layers has led us to miss many, many discoveries!
    James Staples James Staples
    Jan. 11, 2010 at 12:11pm
  • Great work Strasser. If you are only looking for chert you will only find chert. as for the rest of the article...hmmm I realize that 130,000 years ago suggest that it was between the two ice ages. You could have metioned that. About the same time as the Swanscomb man in England. what was he a sort of Pre Neanderthal? If Neanderthals DNA can be 800,000 years old what way were they crossing the Straights of Gibraltar ? I have yet to hear of a Neanderthal from central Africa. Any monkey with half a brain can travel to a new location. Actually if he had half a brain he might have been chased to a new location. Where he would have to find something to eat. being hungry he would try anything. So you don't find his remains is that because you are looking for chert and can't find quartz? You are on the right track Strasser
    John Zilka John Zilka
    Jan. 11, 2010 at 3:15pm
  • I am well aware of Bednarik's research (SN: 10/18/03, p. 248) and apologize for not including a reference to my Science News article about his research in the current story. I take a bit of solace in noting that Bednarik has forgotten about that article too.
    --Bruce Bower
    Bruce Bower Bruce Bower
    Jan. 12, 2010 at 9:53am
  • I question his connection connecting Homo Erectus to the stone axes found in Crete solely on the basis that they are similar to the ones found in Africa. First, have there been any Homo Erectus remains in the locals of the hand axes? Second, where are the locations in Africa that the ones in Crete are being compared to? North, East, Central or South? Third, has there been any biological material which can be dated to substantiate Strasser's claims? Fourth, wasn't modern human (Homo Sapiens Sapiens) already around approximately 70,000 years before the date of the axes? So wouldn't that make the axes more of a likely hood that they were just man made and only 'resembled' the axes from Africa?
    James Morgan James Morgan
    Jan. 17, 2010 at 7:43pm
Post a comment (Please note: All links will be removed from comments.)

Please login or register to participate.

Advertisement
Reader Favorites:
seperator
SN on the Web:
seperator