- :: Atom & Cosmos
- :: Body & Brain
- :: Earth
- :: Environment
- :: Genes & Cells
- :: Humans
- :: Life
- :: Matter & Energy
- :: Molecules
- :: Science & Society
- :: Other Topics
- :: Science News For Kids
Tiny clusters of aluminum atoms may be able to quickly extract pure hydrogen from water, a new simulation suggests. The results offer an incredibly detailed view of how the molecules react and may help scientists develop new ways to produce pure hydrogen-based fuels, researchers report in an upcoming Physical Review Letters.
Many energy experts consider hydrogen an ideal fuel, because mixing it with oxygen produces nothing but energy and water. But transporting and storing pure hydrogen is a safety challenge, and current methods of producing it on an industrial scale require more energy than the resulting hydrogen fuel contains. What’s more, that energy typically comes from natural gas, coal or other fuels that produce greenhouse gases. In order to reap hydrogen’s benefits, researchers need to find ways to create, transport and store it in a safe and sustainable way.
Computational physicist Priya Vashishta of the University of Southern California in Los Angeles is working on a way to eliminate the storage problem by producing hydrogen “on the fly.” He and colleagues from USC and Kumamato University in Japan generated complex computer simulations of a glob of 17 aluminum atoms suspended in water. This group of atoms, called a superatom, takes on special attributes that might change how the aluminum reacts with water molecules.
In their simulations, Vashishta and colleagues watched the water and aluminum molecules waltz through a choreographed routine. The effect, Vashishta says, was similar to watching characters dancing in a movie as the frames flicker by. Electrons and hydrogen ions moved around before the reaction ultimately produced three hydrogen molecules, each of which contains two hydrogen atoms, all in about 3 picoseconds. “The simulation tells us how the hydrogen is produced, and we can tell you absolutely, totally and completely the process by which it is produced,” says Vashishta.
Earlier experiments by other researchers have hinted that aluminum superatoms react with single molecules of water vapor. Small molecules such as the aluminum superatom have a high ratio of surface area to volume, giving them an advantage over bulkier substrates in reaction rates, Vashishta says.
Some regions of the superatom were hungry for electrons, while other regions wanted to give electrons away, the researchers found. As these sites began interacting with the surrounding water molecules, hydrogen atoms swiftly jumped from one oxygen partner to another, ultimately ending up on the aluminum superatom. After another series of complicated hydrogen bond switching events, a hydrogen atom then left the aluminum to join another hydrogen atom. The two hydrogen singletons were produced strategically close to one another, easing their ability to find each other and form a stable two-hydrogen molecule. Their closeness is “quite remarkable,” says Vashishta.
The results provide a more complete view of how tiny aluminum particles can catalyze hydrogen production. But these aluminum superatoms may not be a viable way to create energy, comments alternative-energy researcher Jerry Woodall of Purdue University in West Lafayette, Ind. “This is interesting science, but it’ll probably not see the realm of practicality in my lifetime,” says Woodall, who has worked on large-scale aluminum catalysts for hydrogen production.
Found in: Matter & Energy and Molecules

- Shimojo, F., et al. 2010. Hydrogen production from water using aluminum-cluster catalysts. In press, Physical Review Letters.
- New data suggest a lighter Higgs
- Two is the magic number
- Researchers create global map of tree height
- Hole from on high
- Taming time travel



Aluminum superatoms are not a viable way to create energy because energy is not created.
It would have been nice to have Woodall follow up his claim with something like that. Any news about someone claiming a useful discovery in the field of producing Hydrogen from water ought to be followed with a standard disclaimer that physically impossible to make more energy than you put into it (not just that "current methods" have a net loss).
The only way this would be useful is if it is extremely efficient so that the net loss is negligible in light of some other benefit from using Hydrogen to power things in other locations. However, there isn't any information in the article about the specific efficiency of this process.
I also would like to see a better explanation of this work. On the face of it, the article seems to portray something like a perpetual motion machine, though we must remember that what being produced here is hydrogen, not energy. A catalyst speeds or slows a chemical reaction, but that doesn't seem to be quite what Vashista is describng here. There would have been no reaction at all without the addition of the aluminum superatom , unless we're talking about random, slow degeneration of water molecules into H2 & O. I'm not sure that can happen, since water is a very stable molecule. So the second law of thermodynamics is, so far as I can see, being sidestepped here. The article does not explain where the energy to push this reaction came from. It had to come from somewhere.
Please login or register to participate.