Latest Issue of Science News


Reviews & Previews

The NASA take on 'Gravity'

An astronaut and a former space-station director consider the reality of the film's dangers

Magazine issue: 
Sponsor Message

In Alfonso Cuarón’s new thriller Gravity, Sandra Bullock plays a reluctant astronaut who wants to complete her space walk to repair an instrument as quickly as possible. Her plans are foiled by a series of terrifying events that have surely crossed the minds of astronauts and space junkies. The stunning 3-D cinematography gives viewers the feeling of being in space and fuels the feeling of helplessness. Here are some challenges Bullock’s character faces (spoiler alert) and their likelihood of happening in reality, according to NASA experts.

Russia blew up its own satellite and created a tsunami of space junk!  Possible, but…
In 2007 China used a guided missile to destroy one of its aging weather satellites, creating hundreds of thousands of smaller pieces of space junk. But the danger the debris posed was to other satellites, not astronauts, says Mark Uhran, who retired last year as NASA’s director of the International Space Station. Most satellites are in geosynchronous orbits about 35,000 kilometers above Earth’s surface, well above the roughly 400-kilometer altitudes of the ISS and most manned flights. Lower space junk can present a threat; NASA does track hundreds of thousands of objects in this zone, and the station’s thrusters can change its orbit slightly to avoid collisions.

I got disconnected from my ship!  Extremely unlikely
NASA can’t prepare for every nightmare scenario, so it relies on a “failure modes and effects analysis” to determine an event’s likelihood. Uhran says NASA calculated the chance of an astronaut coming untethered as infinitesimally small. Just in case, astronauts perform space walks in pairs, and they wear thruster belts that can provide an emergency boost — though not a powerful one. No spacewalkers, or their steel tethers, have ever been struck by debris, though NASA astronaut Mike Massimino says astronauts practice returning to a vehicle if a spacesuit is punctured.

We can’t get home!  Extremely unlikely
NASA requires all missions to have a backup means for return, usually an escape vehicle. The ISS has two Russian Soyuz capsules. During Massimino’s last mission to upgrade the Hubble Space Telescope, NASA had a backup shuttle ready to launch in case of trouble. “You always have to have a lifeboat,” he says.

The space station is on fire!  Possible
“Fire is one of the greatest hazards that can occur on the space station,” Uhran says. In 1997 an oxygen canister ignited on the Russian station Mir, unleashing smoke and meter-high flames. Cosmonaut Valery Korzun managed to douse the flames. Had he failed, half the crew could have died because the fire blocked access to one of the two Soyuz escape capsules. Uhran says that materials on the space station have high ignition temperatures so that small fires won’t spread. 

Note: To comment, Science News subscribing members must now establish a separate login relationship with Disqus. Click the Disqus icon below, enter your e-mail and click “forgot password” to reset your password. You may also log into Disqus using Facebook, Twitter or Google.

X