Growth Curve

The inexact science of raising kids

Laura Sanders

Growth Curve


Growth Curve

Noisy toys mute conversations

parent and kids play with toys

Non-noisy toys encourage parents and toddlers to talk, while electronic toys may do the opposite, a new study suggests. 

Sponsor Message

On her first birthday, my younger daughter and I went to a toy store to pick out a present. With nonstop grabs and insistent squeals, my daughter wasn’t choosy. But I had some reluctance as we stared down an aisle crammed with big, bright, noisy things. Life with two little kids is loud enough without buying more decibels for the living room.

The store clerk hid his eye rolls as he pointed us to the nook that held batteryless toys, where we found some balls that fall through holes onto a xylophone (a hit, it turns out).

In that instance, my decision to avoid an electronic toy was 100 percent curmudgeon. But a new study gives me and other auditorily assaulted parents an even better reason to reject battery-operated toys: Electronic toys mute the conversations between parents and babies that are so important for language development.

“When there’s something already making noise and talking, parents may be taking a backseat or more on the sidelines, letting the toys do the talking as opposed to talking over the toy,” says researcher and speech-language pathologist Anna Sosa of Northern Arizona University in Flagstaff.

Sosa eavesdropped on conversations between 26 Flagstaff babies and their parents with audio-recording devices tucked into the babies’ pockets. Sosa provided three kinds of toys: electronic toys that included a baby laptop, cellphone and talking farm; traditional toys that included wooden puzzle, a shape-sorter and rubber blocks; and five board books. She wanted to see if the type of toy made a difference to the language she’d pick up. Turns out, it did.

During 15-minute play sessions with electronic toys, parents said about 40 words per minute on average. Parents’ word count jumped to about 56 words per minute for traditional toys. And books prompted even more language, with parents saying about 67 words per minute.

Between 10 and 16 months old, these babies were just on the cusp of speaking. Their languagelike sounds showed similar patterns to those of their parents, with electronic toys eliciting the fewest sounds and books eliciting the most.

Overall quantity wasn’t the only thing that changed. The quality of conversations, measured by the number of turn-taking, parent responsiveness and content-specific words (“piggy” while playing with the talking barn, for instance), was lower for electronic toys than for traditional toys and books, Sosa found. “I found that the types of toy really do have a big impact on what the parents do,” she says.

Another recent study highlights how reading time is packed full of language.  Twelve-month-old babies made more wordlike sounds (“ba” or “ma”) while reading a book with their moms than while playing with puppets or toys. And during book time, mothers responded to their babies’ wordlike sounds more than vowel sounds (“aaah”).

In a sense, book reading may prompt parents to tune in more to babies’ verbal attempts. While reading, “the mothers are picking up on ‘Hey, that sounds like you’re trying to say a word,’” says study coauthor Julie Gros-Louis, a developmental psychologist at the University of Iowa in Iowa City. “It’s almost like an expectation,” she says. “And I don’t think it’s conscious.” 

These studies suggest that one of the best ways to have a language-friendly home is to design it with that goal in mind. That means lots of books and blocks and puzzles, and fewer noise-makers that often promise to boost learning, but in fact do the opposite.

I think an outright ban on electronic toys is too harsh, not to mention unrealistic. Right now, my kids are obsessed with a dancing robot. And while he’s grooving and singing, my daughters aren’t learning language (though they have leveled up their dance moves). But he sure is a blast, if you’re into that kind of thing.

Sosa recommends viewing these toys as the electronic candy they are. “That’s entertainment,” she says. “That’s something the child might like to do for a few minutes.” But a cute little robot voice shouldn’t be the only one a baby hears.  

Human Development

Young infants have perceptual superpowers

By Laura Sanders 1:53pm, January 8, 2016
Babies have superpowers that let them see and hear things that adults can’t.
Human Development,, Neuroscience

Iron helps growing bodies, but could too much do harm?

By Laura Sanders 7:00am, December 9, 2015
Iron fortification has been a public health victory in the fight against childhood anemia. But too much iron may be a cause for concern, scientists propose.
Human Development,, Neuroscience

Young babies live in a world unto themselves

By Laura Sanders 2:51pm, November 6, 2015
Young babies don’t let information from the outside throw off their touch perception, a finding that has clues for how babies experience the world.
Human Development

Why kids look funny when they run

By Laura Sanders 7:00am, October 11, 2015
Kids’ short legs give them little time to push high off the ground, a constraint that leads to the jerky toddler trot.
Human Development,, Language

For kids learning new words, it’s all about context

By Laura Sanders 3:28pm, September 21, 2015
By recording the first three years of life, researchers get hints about a child’s language development.
Human Development

Backwash from nursing babies may trigger infection fighters

By Laura Sanders 11:36am, September 15, 2015
A nursing baby’s saliva may get slurped back into mom’s breast, where it stimulates an immune response.
Health

Five reasons to not totally panic about ticks and Lyme disease

By Meghan Rosen 6:00am, August 21, 2015
We’ve been trained to panic about tick bites and Lyme disease. There are risks to both — and here are some key facts.
Neuroscience,, Human Development

Study finds early signs of bookishness in a child’s brain

By Laura Sanders 3:55pm, August 18, 2015
Children from book-friendly homes show higher brain activity when they hear a story, but there’s more to learn about how reading affects growing brains.
Microbes,, Human Development,, Health

Antibiotics early in life may have lingering effects

By Laura Sanders 11:17am, July 31, 2015
A study in mice show long-lasting effects from courses of antibiotics early in life.
Neuroscience,, Human Development

In children, a sense of time starts early

By Laura Sanders 10:32am, July 16, 2015
Minutes, hours, days and years start to take on new meaning as children acquire a deeper concept of time.
Subscribe to RSS - Growth Curve