Herd immunity may be preventing more big outbreaks
Jason Hoekema/The Brownsville Herald via AP
Less than a year after the World Health Organization declared Zika is no longer a public health emergency, the virus seems to have fallen from public consciousness, at least outside of heavily affected areas. The mosquito-borne virus staged a massive assault on the Western Hemisphere in 2015 and 2016 (SN: 12/24/16, p. 19), but this year, Zika appears to be in retreat.
In the hardest-hit countries, data from each country’s department of health shows a striking drop in locally acquired cases, that is, ones caused by bites from local, infected mosquitoes. For instance:
- Brazil had over 216,000 probable cases in 2016; as of early September, the new cases for 2017 were around 15,500.
- Colombia tallied more than 106,000 suspected and confirmed cases from 2015 to the end of 2016. This year, new cases have plummeted, with around 1,700 by mid-October.
- Mexico went from about 8,500 confirmed cases in 2015 and 2016 combined to around 1,800 by early October of this year.
The numbers have also dropped in the United States and its territories. In Puerto Rico, Zika cases hit nearly 35,000 in 2016, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports. But this year, less than 500 cases have been tallied as of mid-October. In the 50 states, the CDC counted about 5,100 cases in 2016. Most were in travelers who had been to places where Zika was active, although 224 were locally acquired in Florida and Texas. So far in 2017, only about 300 cases have been reported as of mid-October, mostly from travelers. Local transmission seems to have come to a standstill, with one suspected case in Texas and one case confirmed in Florida.
That doesn’t mean Zika’s days are numbered. If Zika behaves like other arboviruses, such as chikungunya and dengue, it will probably stick around. Arbovirus diseases tend to be cyclical, says public health researcher Ernesto Marques of the University of Pittsburgh. “You have big booms, then they drop. Then a few years later, they come back again.”
Why the dramatic rise and fall? The likely answer is herd immunity, says epidemiologist Albert Ko of the Yale School of Public Health. “Zika came in like a bulldozer,” he says, and many people in the Americas who coexist with Aedes mosquitoes, which transmit Zika, were infected. Now, “there are so many people who’ve already been exposed to the virus and are presumably immune, it kind of protects indirectly the people who haven’t been infected. So that’s probably happened.”
Zika virus transmission is more complicated since mosquitoes are involved, Morens says. Other factors such as how dense the human population is in an area, mosquito abundance and climate also play a part. “But it’s clear there is some level of herd immunity,” he adds. “We see it with all of these arboviruses that cause epidemics. They burn out because the virus can’t find enough people to infect.”
It’s difficult to assess what percentages of populations across the Americas have been exposed to Zika. While the virus is linked to birth defects (SN Online: 9/28/17) and to neurological problems in adults, most cases lead to mild or no symptoms. Some infected people probably don’t get medical assistance, leading to missed cases. And diagnostic tests looking for antibodies against Zika can’t always tell the difference between Zika and dengue infections.
It’s also unclear for mosquito-borne diseases how widespread infection needs to be before herd immunity kicks in. Scott Weaver, a virologist at the University of Texas Medical Branch in Galveston, notes that in places where chikungunya immunity was measured, “typically from 20 to 50 percent of the population became infected as the outbreak swept through a given region.” At those levels, “we don’t see very efficient transmission.”
Though the downtick in Zika cases is evidence of herd immunity, whether a person’s past infection leads to lifelong immunity is unknown. The general understanding of Zika’s close relative dengue is that, once someone has had an infection with one type of dengue virus, that person is protected from further infections from that type. But a 2016 study in the Journal of Infectious Diseases found reinfections are possible. So Zika immunity might wane over time, perhaps leading to reinfections, says pediatrician and microbiologist Peter Hotez of Baylor College of Medicine in Houston.
It’s also possible that Zika will find an animal host in the Western Hemisphere, providing the virus a way station of sorts until the human population is more susceptible again. Researchers have detected Zika in capuchin monkeys and common marmosets, which both reside near humans in Brazil (SN: 3/4/17, p. 15).
All of the unknowns make it hard to predict when Zika will reemerge. There may be epidemics here and there, and then years later it pops up “in a place, in a time you can’t predict,” Morens says. “The Zika virus will be around indefinitely.”
J. Waggoner et al. Homotypic dengue virus reinfections in Nicaraguan children. The Journal of Infectious Diseases. Vol. 214, October 1, 2016, p. 986. doi: 10.1093/infdis/jiw099
M. Aliota et al. Zika in the Americas, year 2: What have we learned? What gaps remain? A report from the Global Virus Network. Antiviral Research. Vol. 144, August 2017, p. 223. doi:10.1016/j.antiviral.2017.06.001
S. Ali et al. Environmental and social change drive the explosive emergence of Zika virus in the Americas. PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases. Vol. 11, February 9, 2017. doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0005135
T. Saey. A mutation may explain the sudden rise in birth defects from Zika. Science News Online, September 28, 2017.
L. Biel. The Zika epidemic began long before anyone noticed. Science News. Vol. 191, June 24, 2017, p. 12.
M. Rosen. DNA may offer rapid road to Zika vaccine. Science News. Vol. 191, March 18, 2017, p. 12.
T.H. Saey. Zika virus ‘spillback’ into primates raises risk of future human outbreaks. Science News. Vol. 191, March 4, 2017, p. 15.
M. Rosen. Year in review: Zika virus devastates Brazil and spreads fear across Americas. Science News. Vol. 190, December 24, 2016, p. 19.