Directions for teachers:
This discussion requires that students have basic knowledge of cell structure and function. The first set of questions can be discussed as a class, or you could ask students to answer the questions with a partner. Then have students read the online Science News article “Sea otters stay warm thanks to leaky mitochondria in their muscles” and answer the second set of questions on their own. Ask students to answer the third set of questions with a partner, and then discuss the third set of questions as a class.
Defining a cell’s powerhouse
1. List some of the main components, or organelles, found in many animal cells.
Nucleus, mitochondria, smooth endoplasmic reticulum, rough endoplasmic reticulum, golgi apparatus, peroxisome, lysosome.
2. Which organelle is in charge of energy production? Describe it.
Student answers will vary depending on each student’s depth of knowledge. Students may say that mitochondria are double membrane-bound organelles that produce most of a cell’s energy. Cells have differing numbers of mitochondria based on how much energy the cells need to function. Mitochondria have their own set of DNA.
3. How does that organelle produce energy? What type of energy is produced and how is that energy used?
Student answers will vary depending on each student’s depth of knowledge. Generally, mitochondria use a process called cellular respiration to pump protons across their inner membrane to produce chemical energy in the form of a molecule called adenosine triphosphate, or ATP. During cellular respiration, energy from food is used to bond a phosphate group to adenosine diphosphate, or ADP, creating ATP. When the cell needs energy to power other biochemical reactions, the newly formed bond can be broken, releasing the energy stored within the bond.
How sea otters do energy differently
1. Explain how mitochondria in the sea otters that scientists studied help keep the animals warm.
In animal cells, mitochondria pump protons across their inner membrane to create and store energy in the form of ATP. In the sea otters studied, instead of making ATP, some of the protons went back across the inner membrane, which released some of that energy as heat. This heat energy helps keep sea otters warm.
2. Draw a simple diagram of a sea otter’s mitochondrion to visualize how the organelle generates heat as described by the Science News article. Then, draw a second diagram of a mitochondrion that belongs to a different species of marine mammal. This mitochondrion should not leak protons across its inner membrane. Use arrows to show the movement of heat energy in each diagram.
Student diagrams will vary, but the diagrams should show protons leaking back across the otter mitochondrion’s inner membrane and heat being released from the mitochondrion. Diagrams of another animal’s mitochondrion should show no protons leaking and no heat being released. Each mitochondrion diagram could show the production of ATP within the organelle.
3. Building on the diagrams you created, draw the body of a sea otter and the body of a larger marine mammal, such as a seal or a whale, around the appropriate mitochondrion. (Note: this drawing will not be to scale.) For the sea otter, draw and label at least one additional adaptation that the animal relies on to stay warm in cold ocean environments. For the other animal of your choice, draw and label an adaptation that the animal may use to keep warm, assuming that this animal does not have leaky mitochondria like sea otters do. Use arrows to represent the flow of heat energy from the animal to the ocean water. Explain your diagrams in the space below.
Student diagrams will vary. All sea otter mitochondrion diagrams should already show heat coming from the mitochondrion. Once students draw an otter around the mitochondrion, those arrows will show heat moving from the mitochondrion to the otter’s body. Students should add another set of arrows to the updated diagram that shows heat going from the sea otter’s body to the ocean water. An additional adaptation that sea otters use to stay warm is a thick fur coat.
If students choose to draw a seal or a whale, there should be no heat arrow going from the mitochondrion to the mammal’s body. There could be a layer of blubber drawn on the outside of the animal with an arrow indicating that the blubber layer keeps some heat inside the body. Since sea otters lose heat faster than seals and whales do, because the otters’ bodies are smaller and have less surface area, arrows in the sea otter diagram should be larger than the arrows in the seal or whale diagram.
4. Name an alternative adaptation that might have helped sea otters stay warm in cold water. Had the adaptation occurred, how might it have affected sea otters’ bodies and behavior?
Otters could have packed on more body fat to minimize the amount of heat their bodies lose to cold water. If that alternative adaptation had occurred, sea otters might be larger and/or slower swimmers.
What comes next?
1. What are some questions the scientists in the article have about the outcomes of the study?
Scientists don’t know what triggers sea otters’ mitochondria to leak protons, and they don’t know whether the trait is genetic or whether it develops from environmental exposure over time.
2. What is a question you have about the study and/or its implications?
Student answers will vary but could mention the methods of the study, possible explanations of the results and whether or not other species also have leaky mitochondria.
3. Brainstorm a research question that would help answer your questions or those of the scientists.
Student answers will vary.
Sign up if you’re interested in receiving free Science News magazines plus educator resources next school year. The Society for Science’s Science News in High Schools program serves nearly 5,000 public high schools across the United States and worldwide.