Growth Curve

The inexact science of raising kids

Laura Sanders

Growth Curve

Growth Curve

Researchers face off over whether newborns are really copycats

baby sticking tongue out

BACK AT YA  Babies start sticking their tongues out shortly after birth. Debate about whether newborns copy such behavior from adults continues nearly 40 years after infant imitation research began.

Sponsor Message

This guest post is by Bruce Bower, who has covered behavioral sciences for Science News for 32 years.

For a landmark 1977 paper, psychologist Andrew Meltzoff stuck his tongue out at 2- to 3-week-old babies. Someone had to do it. After watching Meltzoff razz them for 15 seconds, babies often stuck out their own tongues within the next 2½ minutes.

Newborns also tended to respond in kind when the young researcher opened his mouth wide, pushed out his lips like a duck and opened and closed the fingers of one hand.

Meltzoff, now at the University of Washington in Seattle, and a colleague were the first to report that babies copy adults’ simple physical deeds within weeks of birth. Until then, most scientists assumed that imitation began at around 9 months of age.

Newborns don’t care that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. For them, it may be a key to interacting with (and figuring out) those large, smiley people who come to be known as mommy and daddy. And that’s job number one for tykes hoping to learn how to talk and hang out with a circle of friends. Meltzoff suspected that babies enter the world able to compare their own movements — even those they can feel but not see, such as a projecting tongue — to corresponding adult actions.

Meltzoff’s report has inspired dozens of papers on infant imitation. Some have supported his results, some haven’t. A new report, published May 5 in Current Biology, falls in the latter group.  The study of 106 Australian babies tracked from 1 to 9 weeks of age concludes that infants don’t imitate anyone.

Nearly 40 years after his classic paper appeared, Meltzoff is sticking his tongue out again —metaphorically. He argues that the new investigation didn’t give babies a fair chance to strut their copycat skills.

In the study, psychologists recorded the frequency of nine actions — tongue stick-outs, mouth openings, smiles, frowns, pointing with an index finger, grasping and making “mmmm” or “eeee” sounds or tongue clicks — shortly after babies observed a female experimenter perform each action. Infants were also shown a spoon protruding through a tube (simulating a projecting tongue) and a box opening up (like a mouth going from closed to open).

At no age did infants consistently copy any action, the researchers say. Babies stuck out their tongues just as often whether they saw an adult smiling or sticking her tongue out, for example.

Other studies have found that babies stick their tongues out when aroused by flashing lights or lively music, notes psychologist Cecilia Heyes of the University of Oxford, who didn’t participate in the new investigation. Newborns’ tongues pop out after seeing an adult do the same thing at close range because the kids are amped up, she contends.

Give the little copycats a break, Meltzoff responds. In the new study, babies saw a total of 11 actions appearing one right after another, with 15 seconds to 1 minute to respond to each demonstration. Newborns need more time than that to coordinate a movement like one they’ve just observed, he asserts. Another problem: the researchers discarded cases of imitation if babies had looked away from a demonstration for more than two seconds. Babies, like adults, often look away when absorbing information or organizing a response, Meltzoff says.

Still, babies repeated the experimenter’s tongue protrusions more than any other action in the new study, he adds.

Obviously, much remains to be learned about how babies think. What’s clear is that psychology and other scientific disciplines must get beyond the current obsession with trying to find the same statistical trend — such as newborns poking out their tongues especially frequently after seeing someone do the same — in different laboratories under conditions that always vary to some extent.

Science needs organizing principles, or theories, that make testable predictions. Meltzoff, for instance, suspects that infants begin sensing how parts of their own bodies move while still in the womb. That helps newborns recognize other people to be “like me” and match their actions to self-produced actions, he theorizes. If studies Meltzoff is now conducting determine that certain parts of infants’ brains are already dedicated to perceiving and moving particular body parts, such as the tongue, that would support the “like me” theory.

Perhaps a future study will pit different theories of how and when infants become copycats against each other. Babies everywhere would appreciatively stick out their tongues.


Here are a few more things for the childproofing list

By Laura Sanders 2:30pm, May 13, 2016
Some seemingly safe objects may be particularly dangerous for little kids.
Human Development,, Health

Here’s some slim science on temper tantrums

By Laura Sanders 9:00am, April 22, 2016
Scientists have mapped the structure of toddlers’ tantrums, but preventives are hard to come by.
Health,, Human Development,, Biomedicine

Should C-section babies get wiped down with vagina microbes?

By Laura Sanders 4:21pm, March 30, 2016
A study suggests that a post-birth rubdown with vaginal fluid offers starter microbes to babies born by C-section. But it might not always be a good idea.
Health,, Biomedicine

The best advice on Zika virus and pregnancy is to know the unknowns

By Laura Sanders 4:05pm, February 12, 2016
There are some practical steps pregnant women and women who want to be pregnant can take to minimize risk of Zika virus infection.
Neuroscience,, Human Development

Noisy toys mute conversations

By Laura Sanders 3:00pm, January 21, 2016
Electronic toys put a damper on the conversations between parents and babies.
Human Development

Young infants have perceptual superpowers

By Laura Sanders 1:53pm, January 8, 2016
Babies have superpowers that let them see and hear things that adults can’t.
Human Development,, Neuroscience

Iron helps growing bodies, but could too much do harm?

By Laura Sanders 7:00am, December 9, 2015
Iron fortification has been a public health victory in the fight against childhood anemia. But too much iron may be a cause for concern, scientists propose.
Human Development,, Neuroscience

Young babies live in a world unto themselves

By Laura Sanders 2:51pm, November 6, 2015
Young babies don’t let information from the outside throw off their touch perception, a finding that has clues for how babies experience the world.
Human Development

Why kids look funny when they run

By Laura Sanders 7:00am, October 11, 2015
Kids’ short legs give them little time to push high off the ground, a constraint that leads to the jerky toddler trot.
Human Development,, Language

For kids learning new words, it’s all about context

By Laura Sanders 3:28pm, September 21, 2015
By recording the first three years of life, researchers get hints about a child’s language development.
Subscribe to RSS - Growth Curve