Latest Issue of Science News

Scicurious

The good, bad and weird in physiology and neuroscience
Bethany Brookshire

Scicurious


Scicurious

That beard is only hot because it’s not cool

A new study suggests that rarity increases the attractiveness of facial hair

James Harden

James Harden of the Houston Rockets might earn some of his attractiveness from his beard as well as his ball-handling skills.

Sponsor Message

Every hipster knows that something is only cool before it becomes popular. There’s no point in liking a band once it hits the big time. That shirt is no good once it’s no longer ironic. And it’s certainly not enough to go clean shaven or grow a short beard — that’s much too mainstream. Recent years have seen a resurgence of moustaches, mutton chops and Fu Manchus. A style that really stands out sticks it to conformity.

It turns out that when people buck the facial hair trend, they may end up making themselves more attractive. A new study published April 16 in Biology Letters shows that either clean-shaven or fully bearded looks become more attractive when they are rare in the population. The study suggests that humans may practice what’s called negative frequency-dependent selection — people rate rare looks as more attractive than they might otherwise. But when we try to figure out why, the interpretations can get pretty hairy.

In every population, there is variation, both in genetics and in how individuals look. But at first blush, this variation doesn’t make a lot of sense. If one particular look is the most attractive and best for the population, sexual selection should make a species converge on a single, popular look. For example, if the best male guppies have stripes, soon all male guppies will have stripes, as females will only mate with stripey males.

But in nature, this is clearly not the case. Guppies come in a wild variety of patterns, and so do humans. In guppies, this variation is a result of negative frequency-dependent selection: Female guppies prefer male guppies that look unusual compared to others, rather than guppies that share common features. This helps keep looks and genes variable, a distinct advantage for the species. So an individual guppy’s attractiveness doesn’t just depend on his shining character, it depends on how rare his looks are in relation to other guppies.

Zinnia Janif and colleagues at the University of New South Wales wanted to see if humans displayed similar negative frequency-dependent selection that explains the wild variation in human appearance.

To investigate, the scientists focused on facial hair in men. Facial hair is an interesting trait to look at because it is so variable. Not only do men differ in whether they can grow a full beard, they also differ a great deal in whether they choose to do so. Janif hypothesized that men might trim their scruff to be distinctive — and take advantage of negative frequency-dependent selection.

With a fortuitous link from a popular science-themed Facebook site, the researchers easily recruited over 1,400 heterosexual women and 200 heterosexual men for their study. Participants viewed 24 average male faces with varying degrees of growth: Clean-shaven, light stubble, heavy stubble and full beard. In some conditions, the four beard lengths were evenly distributed among the photos. In some, either the clean-shaven condition or the fully bearded condition was rare. The participants rated the attractiveness of the faces.

The scientists found that neither the clean-shaven nor the fully bearded faces were very attractive when the facial hair types were evenly distributed. But when the clean-shaven faces or the bearded faces were the rare beards in the bunch, the participants, both men and women, rated them as significantly more attractive.

But don’t let this fool you. The heavy-beard and no-beard conditions were rated the least attractive under control circumstances. And making the clean-shaven or bearded look rare didn’t exactly make them the facial hair styles of the year. It only made clean chins or furry ones more attractive than they had previously been. When it comes to general attractiveness, says Rob Brooks, an evolutionary ecologist at the University of New South Wales and an author on the study, “guys should do heavy stubble if they possibly can.”

The results suggest that humans do indeed use negative frequency-dependent selection when judging the attractiveness of facial hair, with a rarer look becoming slightly more attractive merely because it is rare. Michael Jennions, an evolutionary ecologist at the Australian National University in Canberra, says that while the study probably doesn’t have major evolutionary implications, “it’s a great example of how to test a question using a rigorous scientific approach.” But understanding why humans might behave this way isn’t so clean-shaven.

After all, most studies seem to show that familiar features are the most attractive. Anthony Little, a psychologist at the University of Stirling in Scotland, says that usually “exposure to a greater number of faces with more hair would increase preferences for face hair and decrease preferences for clean-shaven faces.” But in this study, a preponderance of hair produced the opposite effect.

Brooks says that it might be a matter of recognizing other people. “One of the things that’s really important in societies is being able to recognize people,” he says. “So I think we base our judgments on variation in facial characteristics. There may be programs in our behavior that favor unusual and distinctive looks.”

A preference for rare facial hair may also just be a matter of novelty, Brooks suggests. One of the most important factors in whether people show this negative frequency-dependent response is what’s going on around you. “If you live on a base in Antarctica with heavily bearded men, the first clean shaven guy you see will probably be very attractive,” he says. Beards can be a competitive point for men, so when clean-shaven men are rare, Brooks hypothesizes that “novelty itself is not particularly interesting. Instead, common things become less interesting.”

Jennions agrees that it could be novelty, up to a point. “Humans tend to place value on the uncommon,” he explains, “but some things will never be attractive no matter how rare.” Little suggests that the study results might show that rarity is attractive not because it’s novel, but because it’s less mainstream. “It may be less a preference for novelty but more a preference for innovation or nonconformity,” he says.

In addition, all of the beards rated in the study were dark, so there’s no data on whether a blond or a red beard might really stand out from the crowd. And of course, the goatee, the soul patch and mutton chops went entirely unstudied.

Anne Houde, an evolutionary biologist at Lake Forest College in Lake Forest, Ill., says that the real importance of the studies lies not in the facial fuzz, but in future studies that might show whether humans display negative frequency-dependent selection of other traits. “The authors cite eye and hair color as other possible traits that do have a stronger genetic basis [than facial hair],” she says, “and whose diversity could be maintained by a generalized preference for less common or novel traits. And such a preference might favor the tendency of people to maximize their individuality through behavioral choices of hairstyle, clothing, etc.”

But why should humans experience this change in preference? After all, while the ability to grow facial hair has associations with high levels of androgens, hormones that stimulate the growth of male characteristics, facial hair itself has limitless styling possibilities. “The main thing for us,” Brooks says, “is that we hypothesize that beards aren’t attractive at all but a matter of competition, but that men would be competitive through beards.” The group’s next study, already in progress, aims to find out more about the relationship between facial hair and masculinity.

And when it comes to your own facial hair, remember, if you can’t stick with heavy stubble, you can always settle for a style that’s rare. It may not make you the hottest guy around, but at least you’ll stick out by the hair on your chinny chin chin.

Follow me on Twitter: @scicurious

Note: To comment, Science News subscribing members must now establish a separate login relationship with Disqus. Click the Disqus icon below, enter your e-mail and click “forgot password” to reset your password. You may also log into Disqus using Facebook, Twitter or Google.

X
Psychology

People prefer to just get pain over with

By Bethany Brookshire 4:53pm, November 25, 2013
A new study shows that people would rather experience pain ASAP, even if it means experiencing more pain.
Neuroscience,, Genetics

Gene that boosts Alzheimer’s risk might protect against it too

By Bethany Brookshire 4:03pm, November 21, 2013
Carrying certain genetic versions of apolipoprotein E is a major risk factor for Alzheimer’s disease. A new study looks at the effects of different types of APOE on the major markers of Alzheimer’s in mice and shows that all forms are not equal.
Epigenetics

Sexy male mice have competitive moms

By Bethany Brookshire 5:18pm, November 19, 2013
Moms allowed to compete for mates produce sons that make sexy pheromones, live hard and die young. How? Epigenetics.
Microbiology

Thank insects and microbes that we aren’t over our knees in feces

By Bethany Brookshire 5:34pm, November 15, 2013
Ever wondered why you’re not drowning in poop? Scientists harnessed the power of citizen science to find the beetles and microbes we can thank for that.
Psychology

Do you want the good news or the bad news first?

By Bethany Brookshire 12:02pm, November 14, 2013
Do you want to hear the good news or the bad news first? A new study purports to answer the question. But can we apply this to how we deliver news? Well, I have good news, and I have bad news.
Animals

The hottest guy guppies stand out in a crowd

By Bethany Brookshire 11:09am, November 13, 2013
A new study shows that sexy male guppies are the ones who stand out the most, the rarest in the crowd. But what is the rare male effect for?
Neuroscience

Brain patterns of haunting memories

By Guest Writer 4:59pm, November 7, 2013
Some fearful experiences stick with us forever. Others we brush off easily. The difference could be in which neuronal patterns are activated in our brains.
Biomedicine,, Technology

The future of the robotic leg

By Bethany Brookshire 6:05am, November 7, 2013
While robotic legs have come incredibly far, the next step, integrating the function into the rest of the body, still has a way to go.
Animals,, Evolution

The reefs are alive with the sound of oysters

By Bethany Brookshire 3:20pm, November 5, 2013
How does an oyster figure out where to settle down in life? It listens for where the party’s at. A new study shows that oyster larvae can detect sound in the water.
Animals

Wag the dog: When left vs. right matters

By Bethany Brookshire 4:49pm, November 1, 2013
Most of us see a wagging dog’s tail and automatically think it’s a good sign. But are some wags more friendly than others? A new study says yes.
Subscribe to RSS - Scicurious