Aliens will be dead before we get their signals, Drake equation update suggests | Science News


Help us keep you informed.

Real Science. Real News.

News in Brief

We probably won’t hear from aliens. But by the time we do, they’ll be dead.

A new Drake Equation calculation suggests ghost signals haunt parts of the Milky Way

12:00pm, March 12, 2018
animation of signals from alien civilizations

CAN YOU HEAR ME NOW?  Electromagnetic signals (blue circles) from alien civilizations will continue traveling through the Milky Way even after the aliens are gone. The appearance of a doughnut hole represents when a civilization dies out.

Sponsor Message

If signals from an alien civilization ever reach Earth, odds are the aliens will already be dead.

In an effort to update the 1961 Drake Equation, which estimates the number of detectable, intelligent civilizations in the Milky Way, physicist Claudio Grimaldi and colleagues calculated the area of the galaxy that should be filled with alien signals at a given time (SN Online: 11/1/09).

The team, which includes Frank Drake (now a professor emeritus at the SETI Institute in Mountain View, Calif., and the University of California, Santa Cruz), assumed technologically savvy civilizations are born and die at a constant rate. When a civilization dies out and stops broadcasting, the signals it had sent continue traveling like concentric ripples on a pond. Part of the Milky Way should be filled with these ghost signals.

If the civilization lasted less than 100,000 years — the time it takes light to cross the galaxy — then the odds of the signals reaching Earth while the civilization is still broadcasting are vanishingly small, the researchers report February 27 at Humans, for example, have been transmitting radio waves for only about 80 years, so our radio waves cover less than 0.001 percent of the Milky Way.

“If the civilization emitted from the other side of the galaxy, when the signal arrives here, the civilization will already be gone,” says Grimaldi, of the Federal Polytechnical School of Lausanne in Switzerland.

Surprisingly, the team also calculated that the average number of E.T. signals crossing Earth at a given time should equal the number of civilizations currently transmitting — even if the civilizations we hear from aren’t the same ones presently broadcasting. Grimaldi is now working on a paper about what it means that we’ve found none so far.


C. Grimaldi et al. Area coverage of expanding E.T. signals in the galaxy: SETI and Drake’s N. arXiv:1802.09399v1. Posted February 27, 2018.

Further Reading

N. Drake. The Drake Equation turns 50: An interview with Frank Drake. Science News Online, November 1, 2009.

N. Drake. The Drake Equation: All in the family. Science News Online, November 1, 2011.

Get Science News headlines by e-mail.

More from this issue of Science News

From the Nature Index Paid Content