Growth Curve | Science News

MISSION CRITICAL

Support credible science journalism.

Subscribe to Science News today.

Growth Curve

The inexact science of raising kids

Laura Sanders

Growth Curve


Growth Curve

Baby-led weaning won’t necessarily ward off extra weight

Babies who fed themselves gained similar amounts of weight as spoon-fed babies

baby eating a banana

Letting babies feed themselves may not prevent them from putting on extra weight. But it sure is fun to watch.

Sponsor Message

When my younger daughter was around 6 months old, we gave her mashed up prune. She grimaced and shivered a little, appearing to be absolutely disgusted. But then she grunted and reached for more.

Most babies are ready for solid food around 6 months of age, and feeding them can be fun. One of the more entertaining approaches does not involve a spoon. Called baby-led weaning, it involves allowing babies to feed themselves appropriate foods.

Proponents of the approach say that babies become more skilled eaters when allowed to explore on their own. They’re in charge of getting food into their own mouths, gumming it and swallowing it down — all skills that require muscle coordination. When the right foods are provided (yes to soft steamed broccoli; no to whole grapes), babies who feed themselves are no more likely to choke than their spoon-fed peers.

Some baby-led weaning proponents also suspected that the method might ward off obesity, and a small study suggested as much. The idea is that babies allowed to feed themselves might better learn how to regulate their food intake, letting hunger and fullness guide them to a reasonable calorie count. But a new study that looked at the BMIs of babies who fed themselves and those who didn’t found that babies grew similarly with either eating style.

A clinical trial of about 200 mother-baby pairs in New Zealand tracked two different approaches to eating and their impact on weight. Half of the moms were instructed to feed their babies as they normally would, which for most meant spoon-feeding their babies purees, at least early on. The other half was instructed that only breast milk or formula was best until 6 months of age, and after that, babies could be encouraged to feed themselves. These mothers also received breastfeeding support.

At the 1- and 2-year marks, the babies’ average BMI z-scores were similar, regardless of feeding method, researchers report July 10 in JAMA Pediatrics. (A BMI z-score takes age and sex into account.) And baby-led weaning actually produced slightly more overweight babies than the other approaches, but not enough to be meaningful. At age 2, 10.3 percent of baby-led weaning babies were considered overweight and 6.4 percent of traditionally-fed babies were overweight. The two groups of babies seemed to take in about the same energy from food, analyses of the nutritional value and amount of food eaten revealed.

The trial found a few other differences between the two groups. Babies who did baby-led weaning exclusively breastfed for longer, a median of about 22 weeks. Babies in the other group were exclusively breastfed for a median of about 17 weeks. Babies in the baby-led weaning group were also more likely to have held off on solid food until 6 months of age.

While baby-led weaning may not protect babies against being overweight, the study did uncover a few perks of the approach. Parents reported that babies who fed themselves seemed less fussy about foods. These babies also reportedly enjoyed eating more (though my daughter’s prune fake-out face is evidence that babies’ inner opinions can be hard to read). Even so, these data seem to point toward a more positive experience all around when using the baby-led weaning approach. That’s ideal for both experience-hungry babies and the parents who get to savor watching them eat.

Pregnancy,, Parenting,, Neuroscience

Motherhood might actually improve memory

By Laura Sanders 11:21am, December 21, 2016
Having a baby changes all sorts of things, including a mother’s brain.
Child Development,, Pregnancy

Database provides a rare peek at a human embryo’s first weeks

By Meghan Rosen 9:00am, December 6, 2016
A new 3-D atlas charts the growth of each and every organ in the developing human embryo, from the heart to the gut to the brain.
Child Development,, Parenting

What not to do when your kid tells a lie

By Laura Sanders 9:00am, November 11, 2016
We teach children that lying is naughty, but it’s actually a sign of good brain development.
Guidelines,, Parenting

Screen time guidelines for kids give parents the controls

By Laura Sanders 6:00am, October 23, 2016
New recommendations for children’s media use are more nuanced than earlier guidelines, a change that reflects the shifting technology landscape.
Guidelines,, Parenting

Baby-led weaning is safe, if done right

By Laura Sanders 9:00am, October 14, 2016
Babies who fed themselves solid foods, called baby-led weaning, were no more likely to choke than spoon-fed babies, a new study finds.
Health,, Parenting

Don’t cocoon a kid who has a concussion

By Laura Sanders 3:00pm, September 29, 2016
Parents should fight the urge to limit kids’ activities after a concussion.
Parenting

Maybe you don’t need to burp your baby

By Laura Sanders 9:26am, September 15, 2016
Everybody does it. But burping babies after a meal may not cut down on crying or spit-ups, a study suggests.
Health

Doctors need better ways to figure out fevers in newborns

By Laura Sanders 12:54pm, September 2, 2016
When a very young baby gets a fever, doctors scramble to figure out the cause. A new type of test may ultimately help identify whether the culprit is bacterial or viral.
Guidelines,, Parenting

Tired parents don’t always follow sleep guidelines for babies

By Laura Sanders 8:00am, August 23, 2016
Night videos revealed parents putting their babies to bed in unsafe environments.
Guidelines,, Health,, Parenting

Keep it simple when choosing a sunscreen for your kid

By Laura Sanders 7:00am, August 14, 2016
For parents swimming in a sea of sunscreen choices, look for a few key attributes.
Subscribe to RSS - Growth Curve