Context

Science past and present

Tom Siegfried

Context


Context

‘Gravity waves’ is an OK way to refer to gravitational radiation

gravitational waves illustrated

Scientists announced February 11 that they have detected the ripples in spacetime caused by a black hole merger, regardless of whether you call those ripples “gravitational waves” or “gravity waves.” 

Sponsor Message

It’s OK to call them “gravity waves.”

Purists insist that the spacetime ripples just discovered by the Advanced LIGO observatories should be called “gravitational” waves. Which in itself is just a shorthand way of saying radiation of gravitational energy via oscillations in the fabric of spacetime. Further shortening that to “gravity wave” is considered by some to be scientifically illiterate, because “gravity wave” is already taken by scientists who study fluid mechanics. In that context, “gravity wave” refers to disturbances in fluids that occur when two fluids meet or layers of different densities (such as in the atmosphere) come together.

For some people unfamiliar with the concept of homonyms, the use of “gravity wave” in fluid mechanics renders illicit its use to describe gravitational radiation. On the other hand, it’s a general rule of good writing to use no more syllables than necessary. Besides, there’s plenty of justification for using the “gravity” shorthand.

Merriam-Webster’s collegiate unabridged dictionaries recognize the astrophysical meaning of gravity wave, for instance. Physicists often use the phrase in casual conversation. And while “gravitational wave” is more common in the scientific literature, plenty of published papers use the shorter form. You can find it in papers published in Astrophysical Journal Letters, for instance, or Physical Review D, or even Physical Review Letters. And the late John Archibald Wheeler, America’s foremost expert on general relativity in the 20th century, once wrote a book with a whole chapter titled “Gravity Waves.”

So if you encounter anybody who chastises you for saying “gravity waves” because the phrase also has a meaning in fluid mechanics, tell them to spend eight minutes listening to Led Zeppelin’s “Stairway to Heaven.” ’Cause you know sometimes words have two meanings.

Follow me on Twitter at @tom_siegfried

History of Science,, Numbers

Nash’s mind left a beautiful legacy

By Tom Siegfried 3:50pm, May 24, 2015
The death of game theory pioneer John Nash ends a dramatic story of genius.
Physics

Nobel laureate foresees mind-expanding future of physics

By Tom Siegfried 12:01pm, May 5, 2015
A Nobel laureate forecasts deeper understanding of physics and new powers for the human mind in the century to come.
History of Science

Old periodic table could resolve today’s element placement dispute

By Tom Siegfried 6:00am, April 23, 2015
A little-known genius figured out where all the elements in the periodic table should be placed long before some of them were discovered.
History of Science

Top 10 science anniversaries of 2015

By Tom Siegfried 12:02pm, April 8, 2015
From genes and dreams to gravity and Kevlar, 2015 offers plenty to celebrate.
Numbers

P value ban: small step for a journal, giant leap for science

By Tom Siegfried 3:18pm, March 17, 2015
Peer-reviewed journals have largely insisted on P values as a standard of worthiness. But now the editors of one journal have banned the statistical tool.
Evolution,, Numbers

Life’s origin might illustrate the power of game theory

By Tom Siegfried 4:25pm, March 9, 2015
Game theory math can describe molecular competition and cooperation, perhaps providing clues to the origin of life.
History of Science

Islamic science paved the way for a millennial celebration of light

By Tom Siegfried 6:06pm, February 24, 2015
Ibn al-Haytham’s book on optics from a millennium ago serves as a good excuse to celebrate the International Year of Light.
Astronomy

Top 10 messages to send to E.T.

By Tom Siegfried 4:29pm, February 13, 2015
Fears that sending signals to alien civilizations would provoke an invasion shouldn't prevent transmitting important messages.
Quantum Physics,, Numbers,, Cosmology

Top 10 scientific mysteries for the 21st century

By Tom Siegfried 8:00am, January 28, 2015
Solving the Top 10 scientific mysteries facing the 21st century will not be all fun but could be mostly games.
Quantum Physics

Physicists debate whether quantum math is as real as atoms

By Tom Siegfried 1:30pm, January 15, 2015
Physicists debate whether quantum states are as real as atoms or are just tools for forecasting phenomena.
Subscribe to RSS - Context