This molecule puts a new twist on the Möbius strip

It’s half as twisty as the paper loops common in math classes

A ring of 13 gray spheres sandwiched by two green spheres, with red and blue regions spiraling around it.

A half-Möbius molecule is made of carbon atoms (gray) and chlorine (green). Red and blue regions show the twisty wave function for electrons added to the molecule. A wave function is a quantum concept that is related to the probability of finding an electron in a given location.

IBM Research and the University of Manchester

A new molecule takes an unexpected turn.

Scientists created half-Möbius molecules, similar to the Möbius strips common in math classes, but half as twisty. It’s a type of topology, or geometrical structure, that is new to molecules, scientists report March 5 in Science.

A Möbius strip is a mathematical oddity that can be made by connecting the ends of a thin band of paper, but twisting one end by 180 degrees. If you run your finger along the loop of paper, you must go around twice before your finger returns to where you started. Scientists dreamed up the idea of a molecule with the topology of a Möbius strip in the 1960s, and since then, researchers have created multiple versions of them.

A ring with a twist in it
A Möbius strip (rendering shown) is a loop with a 180-degree twist in it. New molecules have half this amount of twist.BojanV03/Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

But half-Möbius molecules weren’t on chemists’ radars until now. In the newly created molecules, electrons can move in regions of space set by a twisted path that rotates 90 degrees in each revolution. That’s half as twisted as a Möbius strip, and it means that four circumnavigations of the path — instead of two — are needed to return to the starting point.

The molecules consist of 13 carbon atoms, arranged in a ring, with two chlorine atoms attached. Those chlorine atoms can impart a twist to the molecule that allows it to form the half-Möbius geometry. Atomic force microscopy and scanning tunneling microscopy, alongside calculations made using a quantum computer, helped confirm the molecule’s structure.

The scientists could even manipulate the molecules’ topology. By giving a molecule some energy, the researchers were able to switch it from a half-Möbius configuration to one with no twist.

Half-Möbius molecules are uncharted territory, so potential applications for the molecules are distant and unclear, says chemist Igor Rončević of the University of Manchester in England. “No one really thought that this sort of thing could exist.”

Senior physics writer Emily Conover has a Ph.D. in physics from the University of Chicago. She is a two-time winner of the D.C. Science Writers’ Association Newsbrief award and a winner of the Acoustical Society of America’s Science Communication Award.