Letters to the Editor


11:51am, August 24, 2012
Sponsor Message

Sun’s speed unclear
Sun’s speed unclear
In “Sun’s shock wave goes missing” (SN: 6/16/12, p. 17), Nadia Drake reports the speed of the sun through space at 83,500 kilometers per hour, or roughly 11,000 km/h slower than previously thought. Yet in the same issue (“At home in the universe,” p. 22), Alexandra Witze reports the speed of the sun relative to galactic rotation as 220 kilometers per second. My first move was to convert Drake’s speed to 23.2 kilometers per second. What is going on here?
Tom Knost, Mills River, N.C.

The apparent conflict in the sun’s speed arises from the fact that different frames of reference are involved. My story about galactic rotation reports on new measurements of how quickly the sun orbits the galactic center, like a dot on a phonograph record circling around and around as the record plays. Nadia Drake’s story covers new measurements of the sun’s motion relative to interstellar space—a much larger frame of reference, more like how the dot and the record are moving together in the space between galaxies. —Alexandra Witze

Anthropomor-phobic scientists
“Mystery neurons found in monkey” (SN: 6/16/12, p. 13) is an example of the preconceived notion that humans are the only animals that ... you fill in the blank.  Did the researchers miss seeing von Economo cells in macaques because they wanted to believe that the cells are related to empathy, self-awareness and consciousness but did not want to believe that macaques might have some of these characteristics? Why were they surprised to find the cells in zebras, which are social animals like us? We are told not to anthropomorphize, but these researchers appear to go to the opposite extreme. Are they anthropomor-phobic?
Leah O’Connor, Chicago, Ill.

More to learn from Science News
I first subscribed to Science News Letter some 50 years ago, as a budding computer programmer using FORTRAN on early “IBM machines” (as we called them), running on vacuum tubes, punch cards and reel-to-reel tapes. As professional demands outpaced my ability to keep up with periodicals, I reluctantly let my subscription lapse. Now retired, I’m once again a subscriber and look forward to reading every article in every issue. You are all to be commended for distilling the current news in so many technical fields into eminently informative and thoroughly enjoyable reading adventures for the layman. Each new issue in the mailbox is greeted with the enthusiasm of the small boy still within me. <> Ed Fisher, Pasadena, Calif.

More from Science News