First 3-D map of a gas cloud in space shows it’s flat like a pancake | Science News



Support nonprofit journalism

Subscribe now


First 3-D map of a gas cloud in space shows it’s flat like a pancake

Its newfound shape could explain why the structure is missing stars

4:25pm, May 10, 2018
gas cloud

MORE THAN MEETS THE EYE  This snakelike gas cloud (center dark area) in the constellation Musca resembles a skinny filament. But it’s actually a flat sheet that extends about 20 light-years into space away from Earth, an analysis finds.

Sponsor Message

For the first time, astronomers have charted the 3-D shape of a cloud of interstellar gas. The map explains why this cloud has failed to form stars so far, and could help test theories of how star formation works.

Astrophysicists Aris Tritsis, now of the Australian National University in Canberra, and Konstantinos Tassis of the University of Crete in Heraklion, Greece, examined a narrow gas cloud in the constellation Musca, located between about 490 and 650 light-years from Earth. What looked like a narrow wisp of cloud that should have been condensed enough to make stars instead stretches 20 light-years away from Earth, the pair report in the May 11 Science.

Such interstellar clouds are the primary birthplaces of stars and come in all sorts of blobby shapes. On the sky, the Musca cloud (sometimes called “the Dark Doodad Nebula”) looks like a long, thin snake about 26 light-years long. It has been “the poster child of a filament or cylindrical cloud,” says Tritsis, who studied the celestial wisp while at the University of Crete.

The cloud’s apparent shape, however, posed a puzzle. If the object was really a cylinder, its mass should have been compressed enough to create stars. But the cloud shows no sign of star formation. Still, astronomical objects can be seen in only two dimensions on the sky. Previous observations of the orientation of light around Musca had suggested that the cloud might extend into space, but it was impossible to tell how deep it went just by looking at it.

So the researchers decided to listen to the cloud instead, analyzing data taken by the Herschel Space Observatory of the cloud’s magnetic field. Wispy stripes called striations are formed by magnetic pressure waves — similar to sound waves — that ripple through the cloud and bounce off of its edges. It’s like the whole cloud is singing, Tritsis says.

The frequencies of these waves can reveal the size and shape of the object they’re ringing through. Musca’s waves exposed a nearly square sheet, extending about 20 light-years out into space away from Earth.

“They found a way to measure this depth,” says astronomer Antonio Magalhães of the University of São Paulo, who was involved in earlier observations but not the new result. “They have a clever way to get this sheetlike structure.”

That structure explains why Musca isn’t forming stars — its gas is spread out more than previously thought. The cloud could start forming stars sometime in the next 10 million years, Tritsis says.

Many physical processes that affect when and how stars form, including magnetic fields, turbulence and gravity, are encoded in the shape of an interstellar cloud. So nailing down Musca’s true form could help refine scientists’ theories of how stars are born.

“Musca can be used as a laboratory to find all this stuff,” Tritsis says.


A. Tritsis and K. Tassis. Magnetic seismology of interstellar gas clouds: Unveiling a hidden dimension. Science. Vol. 360, May 11, 2018, p. 635. doi:10.1126/science.aao1185.

Further Reading

A. Grant. Newfound gas cloud may be graveyard of first stars. Science News. Vol. 189, February 6, 2016, p. 9.

C. Crockett. Stellar nursery gives birth to quadruplets. Science News. Vol. 187, March 21, 2015, p. 17.

G. Popkin. Some gas clouds refuse to collapse. Science News Online, January 31, 2014.

Get Science News headlines by e-mail.

More from Science News

From the Nature Index Paid Content