The fruits of nanotechnology could transform the food industry
When it comes to nanotechnology, almost every industry wants a piece of the action. For more than a decade, the electronics industry has been exploiting the tools of nanotechnology for the development of high-performance computer chips. More recently, biotech companies have begun harnessing the same tools for diagnosing and treating disease. Now, the food industry is turning to nanotechnology as it searches for innovations that could bring safer, healthier, and tastier products to the public.
On the food industry's wish list are low-cost sensors that quickly signal the presence of foodborne pathogens, filters that remove undesired compounds from food and beverages, and nanoparticles that store flavors and nutrients inside food and release them at designated times and places in the body.
"Food is the ultimate complex mixture," says materials scientist David Weitz of Harvard University. "The texture of the food, the taste of the food, the functionality of the food are determined to a large degree by how you mix the different components together."
Understanding how all the individual ingredients in foods interact at the molecular scale—the nanometer scale, that is—should help researchers control these interactions more precisely, Weitz says.
In 2000, Kraft Foods, headquartered in Northfield, Ill., began sponsoring one of the most concerted efforts to apply nanotechnology to food R&D. Known as the NanoteK Consortium, its members include researchers from 15 universities, 3 national labs, and 3 start-up companies. By funding research in nanotechnology, the multibillion-dollar food giant expects to churn out a new generation of "smarter" and more personalized food products, says Manuel Marquez, director of the consortium.
Kraft is not alone. Although officials at Nestlé's research center in Lausanne, Switzerland, are tight-lipped about their plans, the company now has a dedicated staff of food scientists investigating the potential benefits of nanotechnology. Meanwhile, many university labs have begun adapting their nanoscale innovations in chemistry, materials science, and biotechnology to meet the needs of the food business.
Marquez says that nanotechnology will enable companies to bring food research and development to the next level. "If we don't understand the interactions at the molecular level, we will not be able to develop new products or materials with new properties," he explains.
As they reach for that new level, some researchers are turning to lessons learned in the electronics industry. Seeking to replace silicon with less-expensive and flexible materials for applications including solar cells and computer displays (SN: 1/31/04, p. 67: Flexible E-Paper: Plastic circuits drive paperlike displays; SN: 8/11/01, p. 86: New method lights a path for solar cells), many electronics firms have been investigating electrically conductive polymers. These same materials could be molded into sensors with nanoscale features that would, within minutes of exposure, detect extremely faint molecular signals of spoilage or foodborne pathogens.
Because the sensors are made from cheap, flexible materials, they could be incorporated directly into packaging for continuous monitoring of food quality, says consortium member Gregory Sotzing at the University of Connecticut in Storrs.
Sotzing and his colleagues are working on a food-spoilage sensor that changes color when it detects a problem. Such a sensor could render obsolete those vague, and frequently inaccurate, "best before" dates printed on many food packages, says Sotzing.
To make the sensors, the researchers coat a piece of glass with a layer of nonconducting, precursor polymer and then pass the fine tip of an atomic force microscope (AFM) over the material's surface. Wherever the electrode-like tip comes into contact with the polymer, it changes the molecular structure of the material, rendering it conducting. With this technique, the researchers can rapidly draw extremely thin electrical lines in the material. Each line would function as a single sensing element, explains Sotzing.
In the Aug. 11 Journal of the American Chemical Society, Sotzing and his team describe how they used their AFM technique to create conducting lines only 45 nanometers wide.
Certain chemicals associated with, say, the breakdown of mayonnaise, binding to the lines would change their electrical resistance in characteristic ways. Sotzing says the materials can be designed so that a change in the resistance of the polymer lines would cause the material to swell and emit light of a particular color.
By varying the chemical composition of the polymer in each line, the researchers can tailor the sensor to detect multiple chemicals or pathogens and to change color in response.
On a more futuristic front, polymer sensors could help a customer analyze his breath to discover his own food preferences. A customer in a grocery store might breathe on a sensor and the device would detect a set of breath chemicals that it would correlate with specific taste preferences or dietary requirements.
Qingrong Huang, a food scientist at Rutgers University in New Brunswick, N.J., is also developing nanosensors, but he's pursuing a different application: protecting the food supply from natural pathogens and biowarfare agents.
While working at IBM's Almaden Research Center in San Jose, Calif., Huang and his coworkers created an insulating material to prevent electronic signals from interfering with each other on computer chips. Soon after moving to Rutgers in the fall of 2002, Huang realized that the same material could serve as a substrate for detecting biological agents. His group is now making small chips out of the material that would go into portable devices to detect pathogens in food products.
Huang's silicon-containing material is riddled with pores just 50 nm in diameter. As in many other sensing schemes, the researchers attach DNA probes to the material's surface. When bits of DNA from a specific pathogen attach to the probes, the complex fluoresces. Because the material is porous, it has a large surface area, and therefore can hold many probes per unit area. This could make the device more sensitive than other sensors, says Huang.
Huang's lab is adapting its design for detecting Escherichia coli and Listeria. The goal, Huang says, is to produce inexpensive pathogen sensors that would enable food companies to monitor their products from the production plant to the grocery store.
The challenge for food companies goes beyond making sure that food is safe to eat. With the aim of improving consumers' eating or drinking experiences, some NanoteK members are using nanotechnology to develop products that give people more choice over which ingredients they consume.
Consider Gustavo Larsen of the University of Nebraska in Lincoln. He's developing filter paper that would remove caffeine from coffee during brewing. By varying the number of filters, users could brew up a different degree of decaffeination with each pot, Larsen notes.
To make the filters, he and his colleagues modified cellulose fibers—the plant-derived material that paper is made of—to recognize the molecular structure of caffeine. A process called molecular imprinting creates billions of minuscule footprints of the caffeine molecule on the filter's surface. As the coffee passes through the filter, the footprints catch the caffeine molecules, while letting the rest of the hot beverage pass through.
The researchers created the footprints in a solution containing caffeine by mixing cellulose fibers with silica, the mineral of sand and glass. The silica particles clustered around the caffeine molecules and then stuck to the fibers. Selectively washing away the caffeine from the solution left behind billions of silica clusters attached to the cellulose—each cluster harboring what was effectively a mold of the caffeine molecule.
After drying the fibers in an oven, the Nebraska team tested the filtration capacity of its new material and found that caffeine stuck to the modified fibers much more readily than to unmodified fibers. When the researchers tested the cellulose on theophylline, a molecule with a chemical structure almost identical to that of caffeine, the filter let most of the theophylline pass through.
"The fibers chiefly recognize one shape," Larsen concludes. Therefore, filter paper made from the imprinted fibers should leave unaltered the essential mix of the coffee's flavor compounds. The researchers' next project is to make actual filter paper out of the imprinted cellulose fibers.
Similarly imprinted filter materials could be used to remove other molecules that "we literally don't want to have in the product," says Marquez. For instance, he notes, molecules such as cholesterol and nicotine that are associated with diseases, or others that produce off tastes, might be removed with properly imprinted filter materials.
It's good for you
As consumer demand for healthier products increases, so does the commercial promise of nutraceuticals—foods and dietary supplements that contain health-promoting ingredients. Incorporating these ingredients into foods is not always easy. For example, fish oil, which contains omega-3 fatty acids and can help prevent heart disease, rapidly breaks down on the shelf. Consumers have to take large doses every day to ensure that they ingest enough of the active form of the fatty acids.
If the nutrients were protected inside nanosize capsules that unload their contents only when ingested, then smaller doses would be sufficient. Fortifying foods with encapsulated material might be an effective means of delivering health-promoting compounds to the body.
What's more, says Marquez, some nutraceuticals break down in the stomach before the body absorbs them. Encapsulating materials that "know" when and where to release their contents—for instance, in the intestine, which is less acidic than the stomach—could enhance absorption, Marquez says.
Funded by Kraft, researchers at a company called Y-Flow in Seville, Spain, are developing a novel way of making tiny droplets for encapsulating nutrients, as well as flavors and aromas. The researchers squeeze two different liquids simultaneously through concentrically arranged nozzles. In one type of droplet, the outer liquid is a slightly conducting polymer and the inner liquid contains the nutrient.
This process produces fine coaxial jets that have one fluid positioned inside the other. An electric field pulls the jets out of the nozzle and causes the stream to break up into nanosize droplets. When the outer liquid is a photosensitive polymer, exposing the droplets to ultraviolet light hardens the shell, encapsulating the second liquid, Y-Flow food scientists have shown.
Regardless of how they encapsulate the ingredients, food scientists can use different materials inside and out to tune the particles to degrade at different rates or under different conditions. For instance, Huang and his colleagues are making nanoparticles out of standard food ingredients such as gum arabic and whey protein. By controlling the density of these natural polymers, they can design capsules that degrade at specific acidities.
Huang's lab is already working on encapsulating an antioxidant compound found in green tea. "Lots of clinical studies have demonstrated green tea's usefulness, but the body has a very low absorbency of it," says Huang. "So, we need to create good delivery systems, and we can do that using natural biopolymers."
Because nanoscale particles are more kinetically stable than larger particles, they are less prone to break down or interact with other ingredients.
Huang says he's working with a beverage company to develop encapsulation materials that store flavor compounds in a drink over a longer period of time than existing materials do. This will allow the company to ship its beverages around the world without the drinks losing their signature taste.
With growing concern over the safety of nanomaterials, consumers might be wary that nanotechnology is making its way into food. Indeed, recent studies have suggested that certain types of nanoscale materials such as carbon nanotubes and buckyballs—structures being tested for use in electronic devices—might be harmful because they could persist in the body and environment (SN: 4/3/04, p. 211: Tiny Trouble: Nanoscale materials damage fish brains).
As a result, "Kraft Foods has been extremely careful in selecting its projects," says Marquez. He is quick to point out that the food industry is not working with those specific nanomaterials that have raised concerns.
"We work with materials that are already in nature," he says. For instance, the materials that researchers are using to develop flavor-encapsulating nanoparticles are derived from natural ingredients that break down in the body. Using degradable and biocompatible polymers to fabricate biosensors for food packaging could also address potential health and safety issues.
Like chefs, food nanoscientists are challenged to come up with the right recipe.
Department of Food Science
65 Dudley Road
New Brunswick, NJ 08901-8520
Department of Chemical Engineering
207 Othmer Hall
University of Nebraska
Lincoln, NE 68588
Kraft Foods R&D
801 Waukegan Road
Glenview, IL 60025
Institute of Materials Science
University of Connecticut
97 N. Eagleville Road
Storrs, CT 06269
Department of Physics
29 Oxford Street
Cambridge, MA 02138
Baeumner, A. 2004. Nanosensors identify pathogens in food. Food Technology 58(August):51-55. Available at [Go to].
Dinsmore, A.D. . . . and D.A. Weitz. 2002. Colloidosomes: Selectively permeable capsules composed of colloidal particles. Science 298(Nov. 1):1006-1009. Available at [Go to].
Goho, A. 2004. Tiny trouble: Nanoscale materials damage fish brains. Science News 165(April 3):211. Available at [Go to].
______. 2004. Flexible e-paper: Plastic circuits drive paperlike displays. Science News 165(Jan. 31):67. Available at [Go to].
Gorman, J. 2001. New method lights a path for solar cells. Science News 160(Aug. 11):86. Available at [Go to].
Perkins, S. 2000. Eau, brother! Science News 157(Feb. 19):125-127. Available to subscribers at [Go to].
Sotzing, G.A., et al. 2002. Preparation and properties of vapor detector arrays formed from poly(3,4-ethylenedioxy)thiophene-poly(styrene sulfonate)/insulating polymer composites. Analytical Chemistry 72(July 15):3181–3190.